But does anybody actually think this is a well themed hotel? Yes, it is a hotel...and it has new rooms... which are fine, but when you see it are you transported to The Riviera? I would say no... It feels like a modern hotel Anytown USA...with a few nice details, but overall an uninspired structure and amenities.
Transported to the Riviera? No. And I don't feel transported to a New England Beach Club at the Beach Club, I don't feel transported to Africa at Animal Kingdom Lodge. I don't feel transported to a classic grand Floridian resort at the Grand Floridian..
So by that definition, pretty much every hotel at Disney is a failure. Sure, some hotels have "more theming," and some have "less theming." Some put more theming into the architecture, some put more theming into the pool or dining, etc.
Now, do I care? Not really. I like a hotel that has nice rooms, nice art, nice grounds, good dining. Riviera checks every box for me. Other resorts also check boxes to different degrees for me.
Real European hotels tend to have very small rooms. So if Riviera had very small rooms, it would be much more authentic and better at transporting me to Europe! But I'd like it a heck of a lot less!!!