Darth Sidious
Authentically Disney Distinctly Chinese
Well, the Muppet fanatics here, who simply cannot FATHOM how anyone could do less than worship those characters, haven't help my feelings about the franchise, I admit. It baffles me why, after what - 8 films (?) and countless specials and TV shows - those fans still want more from what is obviously a pretty dry well. They keep griping about why Disney hasn't released all of the show seasons beyond the first 3 on DVD - well, maybe the reason is that the DVDs don't sell well, just like all of the other merchandise. Duh! Disney's out to make a dime, not preserve the legacy of someone who had nothing to do with the development of the Disney company.
I dislike the idea of Star Wars and Marvel being in Disney parks too, FWIW. Especially Marvel. Let that stay in Universal where it belongs. I'm a Disney purist when it comes to the parks. I go to the parks to see Disney-based attractions, not Stan Lee and Jim Henson-generated stuff. I bet most Disney park visitors feel the same, but of course that's conjecture on my part (but I think the revamp of DCA in California proves me right. Iger himself admitted that the reason the first DCA version failed was because there wasn't enough Disney in it. To which I say again: Duh!)
I'm glad we agree about Mary Poppins. It's ridiculous that the crown jewel of Walt Disney's film production career is so ignored by all of the parks. There are great possibilities there. I just hope that somehow, someday, new leadership in the Disney company will see them and make them happen.
I actually would say I agree with with your opinion on Disney purism if we are talking Magic Kingdom and Disneyland. DHS however I don't mind celebrating some other non traditionally Disney movies along with a heavy dose of Disney. I love GMR for example and I think with the park's concept of reaching for all sorts of IP I enjoy something well done. That said I think if they kept Muppets it should be done well and not halfway.
I was thinking earlier in regards to Mary Poppins that it would work well in the UK pavilion since they've already horseshoed IP into Epcot or as part of a dark ride where each show scene was a celebration of classic and popular movie music. In the music ride you could include both Poppins and classic Disney Animation that otherwise wouldn't have garnered enough support for a standalone attraction.