Star Wars: Galaxy's Edge vs. Toy Story Land?

[APirateoftheCaribbean]

Theming? Dining? Attractions? Which ones are better? Let me know! Edit: I've added Pandora from a request. Which I think would be a great addition.

 

[Poseidon Quest]

Can I cast a vote for Pandora? I find it far more interesting in design and has a noticeable degree of actual effort put into it.

 

[APirateoftheCaribbean]

Alright, I'll add it.

 

[APirateoftheCaribbean]

Here we go.

 

[wdw2011por]

Star Wars: Galaxy’s Edge. Huge Star Wars fan and loved everything about it. The dining was great, RotR was immersive, and the land itself was such that I could spend all day there and feel like I was on another planet/in another world.

 

[CosmicRays]

Galaxy’s edge, especially at night!

 

[JIMINYCR]

Star Wars beats out both Pandora and TSL in all categories. Pandora comes in very close behind. But I'm more of a SW fan than Avatar so I know thats swaying my voting.

 

[dmw]

Very close between SWGE and Pandora. Both are very well themed. But, Pandora has the edge for me because of the beauty both day and night. Oh, and Satu'Li Canteen in Pandora is sooo good!

 

[UNCgolf]

I've never even seen Avatar and absolutely loved Star Wars at one point in my life (my enthusiasm has waned over the years, especially with the multitude of mediocre movies), but I think Pandora is the best. It's gorgeous.

Galaxy's Edge was disappointing for me. Rise of the Resistance looks fantastic (haven't been on it because I didn't get a boarding group), but Smuggler's Run is not very good and the land as a whole was kind of bland. There are some neat details here and there (the Falcon and some of the other ships especially), but I walked around for maybe two hours and was basically done with it and I'm not looking forward to getting back. It's certainly not bad, but it could/should have been so much more than it is.

Toy Story Land is a joke and not comparable to either of the others.

 

[TotallyBiased]

Pandora and GE are my two favorite lands in all of WDW. I'd have to declare a tie. Pandora is breathtakingly beautiful. And I geeked out hard in GE. I may have even teared up a bit standing in front of the Falcon while mumbling, "Chewy, I'm home."

Nope, can't choose.

 

[Little Green Men]

Pandora and GE are my two favorite lands in all of WDW. I'd have to declare a tie. Pandora is breathtakingly beautiful. And I geeked out hard in GE. I may have even teared up a bit standing in front of the Falcon while mumbling, "Chewy, I'm home."

Nope, can't choose.

You’re allowed to select both