I think most people are aware Splash has always pretty much had a limited shelf life. I think its just the "when" is the big discussion right now. "When" and "How"
Agreed. There's also a fine line between erasing and
demolishing an attraction from the parks entirely, and re-theming an already existing attraction with good bones. The sensationalism has been nothing but exhausting, and at times I've been worried they'd go after my favorite attractions for the same reason Splash was targeted. I must realize, that Splash was a special case among the other attractions at the park, due to its ties to SotS, which, keep in mind, is almost impossible to justify in today's world without removing the SotS theme entirely. Their hands were tied... I also don't think Frederick Chambers is a part of some sick sadistic cult of maniacs who want to purposefully deface the parks...
JC is the first example thus far of one of Walt's classics being altered, and so far if this trend continues, let's hope the other beloved classics overseen by Walt, receive the JC treatment, and not the SM treatment (which, again, is highly unlikely).
Imagine if they decided to demolish all of SM for a PatF E-ticket... then I'd be more concerned with what's going on at WDI, because let's face it, the general public loves SM because it's a
thrill attraction. Not because they want to see defunct America Sings AAs (although funnily enough, as an animatronics enthusiast, that's the main reason I enjoy the attraction). Also, with this re-theme, they'll be able to keep the name Splash Mountain intact. SotS
never had any significance to the name Splash Mountain, and neither does PatF. Think of it this way... Space Mountain constantly receives overlays, and hyperspace mountain is very much similar to this situation with SM. Even if its temporary, it dramatically alters an already existing experience with good bones, using a preexisting IP, and while the SM re-theme is permeant, the only reason that's the case, is because they want to avoid a PR nightmare. The biggest shock to me thus far, has been the removal of the SM soundtrack, which is also in my eyes, the biggest loss coming out of this re-theme. It really sucks that we'll be losing some amazing compositions, but if done correctly, they could easily adapt the PatF soundtrack into a similar sounding arrangement to that of SM's soundtrack.