Re: Re: Re: Let's Go For The Big Picture
Danger, small book ahead...
Originally posted by James
WDW has taken great steps over the years to foil "the evil ticket resellers". Florida even passed a law on behalf of WDW that makes it illegal to resell admission media. Disney has tried photo ID's, finger scans, computer checks and other methods to prevent dishonest use of admission media. The idea is to make sure that only one person can use the admission media.
This is, at best, moronic (I realise that you, James, are not personally defending this belief in your statements). What a ticket purchaser acquires is a number of admissions to the theme parks. Who *CARES* about the identity of the user? Following this thought, it MUST be illegal for my wife to use the tickets that I buy. Or, I MUST NOT give my unused tickets to my friends. (But, I hear you cry, these other people aren't buying the tickets from me -- don't get me started on the rights that were originally purchased and how those must, logically -- if not legally -- transferrable).
Well, the wristband does just that! It's the next best thing to putting a microchip in your head. Instead the chip is in the wristband and it "learns who you are" and only you. You can take it off and put it back on just like a wristwatch but it only works when it's on your wrist. Once programmed, it won't work for anyone else but you and it can do anything the current admission media can do and much more! It's not a passive system in that it will "talk back" to WDW. It will track you all over the property. Sure, I know it sounds like Orwell's "1984", but it will help Disney to respond to the needs of the guests as well as providing WDW with a wealth of information.
I am unwilling to trade my privacy and information for a little more convience that WDW *MIGHT* be able to provide to me. Let me dissect your examples...
I'll provide just a few examples because I'm sure you can think of many more. Just imagine if a dispatcher in "transportation central" was able to look at a map of WDW and see the location of every guest in real time as they moved about the resort. Just imagine if there was a disaster such as a fire.
In this case, it is unimportant where I, as an individual, am standing. What matters is where the the crowds are with respect to any particular disaster. Cameras manage this much better than any computer-controlled display ever could.
Just imagine not having to wait more than 3 minutes to ride Test Track or more than 2 minutes to wait for a bus back to your resort.
These are bull**** arguments. Any popular ride will, by definition and design, have more people waiting to use it than there are positions to ride. The only way to have REALLY short wait times are to limit the number of people who may wait in line, and have someone else plan your day down to the minute. Along with privacy issues, I won't allow anyone (not even my wife) to plan my time for me that tightly.
Nearly the same comment can be made about the busses. There are a (very) finite number of busses and seats. With any finite resource, the only way to guarantee a "couple of minute" wait is to have busses sitting idle waiting for a user. This is contrary to any resource utilization scheme I have ever seen or used. Disney would be absolutely insane to consider this resource scheme.
And imagine if Tramp did punch a CM in the groin. WDW could track him down!
This point has, at least, *SOME* small amout of merit associated with it. The wristband *could* be used to track down an individual, but that is based upon an assumption that only one person was near some offense, or that all possible parties are easily traceable, and that the system is indeed, as some have suggested in this thread, virtually error free. Mind you the RMS Titanic had been described as "virtually unsinkable."
In any event, the wristband data would be worthless from a legal standpoint -- if such an event were to go to court. And besides this, you are suggesting that I surrender my privacy simply so that SOME offenders MIGHT be caught more easily? I know the world has changed greatly since 9/11/2001, and that law enforcement agencies have been given unprecedented, and probably unconstitutional, powers; like Benjamin Franklin, I am unwilling to surrender my freedom for a little security (Fade to American flags waving as patriotic music swells...).