Phroobar
Well-Known Member
Sure. We need more input from the guy that gave us Jar Jar, Jake Lloyd and Hayden Christensen.
What we really need is Dave Filoni. See the Clone Wars, Rebels and the Mandalorian.
-
Welcome to the WDWMAGIC.COM Forums!
Please take a look around, and feel free to sign up and join the community.
Rise of the Resistance Condition
- Thread starter TheRealBobIger
- Start date
What we really need is Dave Filoni. See the Clone Wars, Rebels and the Mandalorian.
shambolicdefending
Well-Known Member
Is there any indication they've even touched it since the shutdown started?
Phroobar
Well-Known Member
There is no way to tell that unless there is someone around here that actually did the work.
1HAPPYGHOSTHOST
Well-Known Member
There was nothing wrong with Lucas' ideas only his execution. Dave Filoni doesn't have a creative bone in his body compared to Lucas' imagination.
Phroobar
Well-Known Member
Whatever.
1HAPPYGHOSTHOST
Well-Known Member
It's true. people can bag on the prequel trilogy all they want for the casting choices or the over use of cgi and green screen or characters constantly sitting down talking with over the shoulder shots, or how awful Jar Jar is until they are blue in the face. No one is disagreeing there. But the majority of the fandom will agree while the execution was bad the overall ideas behind the prequels were solid. Just Lucas needed another writer and probably other directors like the OT.
Disney Irish
Premium Member
You obviously haven't been paying attention to the fandom then. Because the prequels were derided for the overall aspect of them. Hell, even Empire was derided by the fandom for being too dark for the longest time. Point is the fandom is always going to be divided over what they consider "good" at that time. By the time the younger generation grows up the sequels and thus the overall 9 films will be hailed as genius.
DrAlice
Well-Known Member
Dave Filoni gave Lucas' ideas the execution they deserved. Does that mean he's creative? I don't know. I'm a scientist, not a film critic.! All I know is that DF makes excellent Star Wars shows that understand the meat of the Lucas stories. That's good enough for me.
FuzzyPicklePal
Member
He also gave us Luke, Han, Yoda, Chewie, Lando, The M.F., Leigh, X-wings, Ewan McGregor, Alec Guiness, James Earl Jones, American Graffitti.....The preq. trilogies are much better than these last three. Also Clone Wars and Rebels were both under George Lucas' creative control. I'll take Jar Jar Binks over the universe breaking "force healing" and whatever that crap was with the Emperor in the last movie. Without googling it how many people even know the story behind Batuu and the black spire outpost. We could do a charcter study on Luke Skywalker and how the last three movies completly destroyed that character
FuzzyPicklePal
Member
This I can get behind. We can point to ESB as evidence of this.
Stevek
Well-Known Member
Midichlorians = good?
I will say I enjoyed the prequels in the moment more than I do now and I consider myself a fairly big SW nerd. It would have taken a lot of work and re-writes to fix some of what George put on screen i.e. much of AOTC. My gut tells me we would have ended up at the same starting and ending point but much of the in-between would have been very different and could have been much better.
Stevek
Well-Known Member
I've yet to hear a single person in the industry say anything bad about Filoni. Dude has a passion for the franchise and has shows he can get quality put on screen IMO of course.
CaptainAmerica
Well-Known Member
CaptainAmerica
Well-Known Member
Empire Strikes Back was neither written nor directed by George Lucas.
el_super
Well-Known Member
Oh. Oh you poor thing.
The prequel trilogies are why George Lucas will never be allowed to make another Star Wars movie again.
chadwpalm
Well-Known Member
- In the Parks
- No
Lucas wrote the story, Brackett and Kasdan adapted it to a screenplay. This is how the prequels should have been done. Lucas is a great idea guy and storyteller, but sucks at dialogue and scene pacing.
FuzzyPicklePal
Member
Under his creative control. Look below you quoted me when I was replying to another person. I never said he wrote or direct them.
This I can get behind. We can point to ESB as evidence of this.
Last edited:
FuzzyPicklePal
Member
I believe he will. There is a rumored Lucas cut of Rise of Skywalker. With that said I would love to hear your opinions on why you think the Disney trilogy is better than the preq. tril.
shambolicdefending
Well-Known Member
Prequal trilogies were never that bad. Not as good as the originals, but in retrospect that was always likely.
They are much better than the sequals, IMO.
The Prequels sold tons of toys and people didn’t stop collecting their merchandise. This is unlike the Sequel Trilogy where people gave up on Star Wars and just ignored all the major characters. Here’s the Sequel Trilogy merchandise at a supermarket. Plenty of Luke Skywalker, but a little Rey in the back.
