I find this fascinating as many hold this opinion. There are some things I just can’t get over (never been there though). World bazaar has a giant metal/glass roof over it - just a weird version for the introduction into the castle park version of main st USA . The biggest thing though - Disney castle parks for me embody Americana as their overall aesthetic - I just can’t imagine getting that feeling with japanese (or French for that matter) being spoken over the PA system. Bizarro world. Good for them having their own versions though
Japan and France definitely on my bucket list - might just skip the parks there though
I guess it's in the eye of the beholder to some extent. Some people hold the Americana of Disney parks as a central part of their appeal, while for me it's been
a part of the US Disney park experience, but not one of
the defining traits of the experience. Maybe that's because I've been to the other parks, maybe it's because there are other theme parks in the US that are
more soaked in Americana to me than any of the US Disney parks are (Silver Dollar City and Dollywood, for one).
I've never felt like one of the big problems of
any Disney park was "this park isn't
American enough".
People get hung up on the World Bazaar roof, but it actually makes a lot of sense in the context of Japan. I'm very grateful that the first time I went to the Tokyo parks was at the end of a month-long term where we had previously traveled to Osaka, Nara, Kyoto, Hiroshima, and Matsuyama before traveling and exploring Tokyo itself rather than visiting the parks. If you visit a lot of Japanese cities before TDR, as I did, you'll see that covered shopping malls like that are
everywhere. In knowing that context, the covered World Bazaar makes perfect sense to the Japanese.
And it's not
just Japanese spoken over the PA system-it's Japanese, followed by English with the
exact same sort of cadence and paternal-authority-voice that you'll hear all over the US parks.
Go to the parks or don't, but I just have always thought it's weird that people treat it as a badge of honor to ignore the international parks when they proudly consume a very,
very similar product in a different context. To me, it's like being a Coca-Cola fiend in the US, but then refusing to drink it in Insert Country Here because you're not in the US or something. Why not if it's available and you know you like it? Who does it hurt? Especially if you're in Asia, as those parks do many things better than the US parks for a cheaper price.
Now, I'd never advise anyone, and especially a first time traveler, to go over there, see the parks, and leave, but if you have plenty of time to see some culture, and you're here posting on a Disney forum, I'd argue that you
should also see the parks. Or at least, it's weirder in my view
to explicitly avoid them. Clearly I'm in the minority, though, because I've seen plenty of people express similar opinions many times.