Yeah, I think Haunted Mansion did have potential, too.
You see, when I first heard that it was being made into a movie, and they had the teaser website up, and the teaser trailer, it looked SCARY. Like, I was expecting another PG-13 movie, because that's what I think the Haunted Mansion's story is worth. After going back to Disney World and seeing the hanging body all completely redone and the scrim looking clearer than ever, I felt like it was a brand new experience for me. Now, with the new Bride in the attic, it makes the ride even creepier. The truth is, no matter how fun and funny you want to try to make a ride, it's still "The Haunted Mansion" and the creepy story behind it is what makes it so eerie.
If you go out and look at fan fiction websites, there are some even scarier stories that people have pieced together thanks to the scenes in the Haunted Mansion. I say, "GOOD FOR YOU! Because the writers of the movie couldn't see what you saw!"
No, they don't have to go making it into a Horror Movie, but I mean... that and the Tower of Terror are both very eerie, and deserve stories that represent it's ghostliness.
I LOVED what they did with the MANSION in The Haunted Mansion. I loved the sets, I loved the scenery, and gosh darn it, I LOVED THE BALLROOM! @_@ Eddie Murphy?.... not so much... That was the only thing I couldn't stand... They tried making it TOO much of a family film, they strayed WAY too far from Pirates potential.
Now you see, if they had discussed Master Gracey as more of a deranged character, and his bride as (how they depict her now)...rather a psycho-path then I think they could have ad a pretty creepy story on their hands. But they would need more serious actors, and a wide range of things to do IN the mansion. You can still have comedy in an action adventure, though, haha. We know that from Jack Sparrow's character. But I think Eddie Murphy and his corny comedy did NOT mix well with the other characters (scary, creepy, gothic, and dark)
But anyway... that's my opinion... But COME ON! Look at that MANSION! @_@ WHO COULDN'T LOVE THAT!