Hypothetical Question

Would you have kept the Sorcerer's Hat if it meant saving the Great Movie Ride?

  • Keep Hat with GMR

    Votes: 62 34.8%

  • Remove hat , put in Runaway Railway

    Votes: 116 65.2%
  • Total voters
    178
HMF

HMF

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
A thought occurred to me. I know in an ideal world The hat would have been removed and GMR would have stayed but I was wondering would you rather have GMR with the Hat or M&M:RR without the hat. I know the two are completely un-related but I was just wondering .
 
GlacierGlacier

GlacierGlacier

Well-Known Member
Personal anecdote:

I'm 18. I used to visit the parks annually with my family when I lived out of state, but now that I live here I visit almost monthly.

I could not ever remember a time before the hat.

For me, the hat was a constant in the park, with it always being at the end of Hollywood Boulevard. I barely even knew the theater was back there.

But the first visit I took since they removed the hat totally blew me away.

The perspective you experience when walking down Hollywood Boulevard towards the Chinese Theater is, in my opinion, more powerful than the Magic Kingdom's castle. It still knocks me off of my feet every time I walk into the park. That view is so, so much more iconic to me than that garbage hat ever was.
 
DisneyFreak

DisneyFreak

Well-Known Member
CaptainAmerica said:
The cast members ruined the Great Movie Ride a long time ago. They did an extremely poor job finding cast members who fit their assigned roles.
Click to expand...

I wholeheartedly agree with this! The ride was definitely not what it once was. We were there a mere month after it opened in 1989 and waited 2.5 hours in line for the ride and it was totally worth it.

If DHS had kept it's actual theme as a working studio and theme park I may have tolerated the hat to keep the GMR
 
Bartledvd

Bartledvd

Well-Known Member
Miss the hat can get a pic of the theater else where in the world but no more hat anywhere. Miss GMR it was a favorite of ours.
 
ppete1975

ppete1975

Well-Known Member
id sacrifice that tired gmr (which if you rode for the first time in its last few years, you were very meh) for anything. It was tired, in my opinion felt cheap even for its time, and unless they had came in and redone all of it (cleaned, better animatronics, better sets) to me it wasn't worth saving (nostalgia and personal memories is why people care, that's also why I was sad about energy the centrorium and wom being gone .. and the shift from classic Epcot). I'm also excited for mickey, this feels more like Disney and is what WDW should have more of. On a separate note, when I was a kid and even now I see all of the IP and non IP and I'm like wheres mickey Donald and pluto??? When I went for the first time I expected a lot more classic characters, so this to me is a great addition!! Sorry I rambled.
 
PorterRedkey

PorterRedkey

Well-Known Member
I hate the hat! I love(d) GMR!!!!!!

Removing GMR, was akin to removing Horizons from EPCOT Center. GMR was the thesis statement for DHS like Horizons was for EPCOT. GMR celebrated movies in a Hollywood park. There is not more of a perfect fit than that. Unfortunately, we will not see a ride like this from Disney again. The long-form dark rides I loved from my youth are all slowly fading away.

If they would have refurbed GMR, keep the hat! If they would have kept the hat and let GMR rot, bring on Mickey!

The sad truth, for many, is MRR will be an improvement over GMR. Maybe not by scope or scale, but definitely the tech and tricks used to tell the story.

This never had to happen as it has been said many times before. Mickey to Animation. Refurb of GMR. Too bad Disney is hurting for money these days. :banghead:
 
Goofyernmost

Goofyernmost

Well-Known Member
It's really easy to be on the winning side when we vote on something that already has happened. In case, you didn't figure it out, I voted for getting rid of the hat and putting in a new ride. The hat had nothing to do with the ride, but, it had everything to do with the sight line that seeing the theater created. Guess what... it's back.
 
Kman101

Kman101

Well-Known Member
rnese said:
I didn't hate the hat. I hated it's location. Possibly it should have been at the top of the hill as sort of a walk-through to enter Fantasmic, or outside the entrance of the park.
Click to expand...

Same. If the hat were outside the entrance or as a walk-through to enter Fantasmic I would have been fine with it. It's location was wrong. Now if say Disney plopped it down at the Studios in Paris it'd probably be an improvement ... or if they created a new movie based park with the hat as the icon.

It's really ironic though. They tear down the hat and now they're putting Mickey in the building his hat blocked for over a decade. LOL. I know those things don't go hand and hand but it's still (in a sad way) amusing. The location would still be terrible but it'd make sense now. Go figure. (Please no one take that as me championing the hat coming back; it's just an ironic situation)
 
Goofyernmost

Goofyernmost

Well-Known Member
Kman101 said:
Same. If the hat were outside the entrance or as a walk-through to enter Fantasmic I would have been fine with it. It's location was wrong. Now if say Disney plopped it down at the Studios in Paris it'd probably be an improvement ... or if they created a new movie based park with the hat as the icon.

It's really ironic though. They tear down the hat and now they're putting Mickey in the building his hat blocked for over a decade. LOL. I know those things don't go hand and hand but it's still (in a sad way) amusing. The location would still be terrible but it'd make sense now. Go figure. (Please no one take that as me championing the hat coming back; it's just an ironic situation)
Click to expand...
Why, oh why, are you championing the hat coming back???? Ugggg! ;););););););)
 
Club34

Club34

Well-Known Member
i could be wrong [and i'm wrong a lot] but i think the new mickey railroad ride is going to be a classic. obviously not a an E ticket, but classic disney magic. i mean if they're going to put in IP then put OG IP. :happy:
 
WDWTank

WDWTank

Well-Known Member
Kman101 said:
Same. If the hat were outside the entrance or as a walk-through to enter Fantasmic I would have been fine with it. It's location was wrong. Now if say Disney plopped it down at the Studios in Paris it'd probably be an improvement ... or if they created a new movie based park with the hat as the icon.

It's really ironic though. They tear down the hat and now they're putting Mickey in the building his hat blocked for over a decade. LOL. I know those things don't go hand and hand but it's still (in a sad way) amusing. The location would still be terrible but it'd make sense now. Go figure. (Please no one take that as me championing the hat coming back; it's just an ironic situation)
Click to expand...
I heard it wasn’t in the place originally intended, and I heard from “multiple sources” that there was supposed to be a ride in there.
 
Magic Feather

Magic Feather

Well-Known Member
WDWTank said:
I heard it wasn’t in the place originally intended, and I heard from “multiple sources” that there was supposed to be a ride in there.
Click to expand...
Originally, it was going to be placed outside what we currently know as the park entrance, with two Ferris wheels flanking the hat, like Mickey ears, but decorated as film reels:
8AA5EC3B-FCFF-40BF-AEEC-5D0DD901691B.jpeg
 
Sir_Cliff

Sir_Cliff

Well-Known Member
Kman101 said:
Same. If the hat were outside the entrance or as a walk-through to enter Fantasmic I would have been fine with it. It's location was wrong. Now if say Disney plopped it down at the Studios in Paris it'd probably be an improvement ... or if they created a new movie based park with the hat as the icon.
Click to expand...
I really didn't like the hat, nor the giant Mickey wand at Epcot which slightly preceded it. When people become nostalgic for Eisner, I think they'd do well to look back to this era when Disney seemed to be actively setting out to ruin their parks by sticking giant "things" over the park icons that stuck around for years, and years, and years. Disney theme parks should be better than amusement parks with giant "Disney" things around in the style of the AoA resort.

As for the WDS Paris, I far prefer the smaller Sorcerer's Apprentice hat integrated into their (otherwise pretty useless) animation building. That at least looks like an organic architectural element that echoes the actual WDFA building. The BAH was just a giant metal hat with Mickey's severed hand alongside for no particular reason. I don't think it was even very attractive.
 
Winter

Winter

Well-Known Member
I'd take the hat if it means we get both TGMR and Runaway Railway (in a different spot)

I never hated the hat though, so...
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom