Greatest QB of All-Time?

PUSH

PUSH

Well-Known Member
Joe Montana. And there's a bit of bias here, but I think Aaron Rodgers will be in the conversation by the end of his career if he stays healthy and keeps playing the way he is.
 
jw24

jw24

Well-Known Member
Being a Giants fan, I would say Eli Manning considering he upset the previously undefeated Patriots and was the king of 4th quarter comebacks during the season he won his second. But in all seriousness, I'd go with Joe Montana simply because he was clutch and delivered when it mattered the most.
 
Dad 2 M & M

Dad 2 M & M

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
jw24 said:
Being a Giants fan, I would say Eli Manning considering he upset the previously undefeated Patriots and was the king of 4th quarter comebacks during the season he won his second. But in all seriousness, I'd go with Joe Montana simply because he was clutch and delivered when it mattered the most.
Click to expand...
Eli is better than Peyton...gasp! Only if you measure by rings and winning big games, but who cares about that? Eli beat Florida TWICE, Peyton NEVER did in 4 tries!!
 
Dad 2 M & M

Dad 2 M & M

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
PUSH said:
Haven't you seen the Blindside? Ole Miss is always better than Tennessee. No wonder Eli won!
Click to expand...
Ole Miss is always a nice sleeper in the SEC...They signed super recruit Robert Nkemdiche out of Grayson High (Both M & M alma mater and youngest M's graduating classmate)...he is the real deal!! They had a top ten recruiting class this year......Incidentally, eldest M graduated with Robert's older brother Denzel, who is also at Ole Miss and was a factor in Robert going there.
 
PUSH

PUSH

Well-Known Member
Dad 2 M & M said:
Ole Miss is always a nice sleeper in the SEC...They signed super recruit Robert Nkemdiche out of Grayson High (Both M & M alma mater and youngest M's graduating classmate)...he is the real deal!! They had a top ten recruiting class this year......Incidentally, eldest M graduated with Robert's older brother Denzel, who is also at Ole Miss and was a factor in Robert going there.
Click to expand...

You can tell college football is more popular down south. Up here we don't talk about recruiting, partly because we're the Big Ten and not the SEC. Up here we get excited when someone from our hometown goes to the Badgers (which is actually happening this year). It was exciting a year or two ago when Louis Nzegwu was picked up as a free agent by the Falcons... only to be cut, but he still was from here! Right now he's with the Panthers. Yeah, we don't have many famous people here, but the voice of Piglet was born here! Exciting stuff! :D
 
Hrudey3032

Hrudey3032

Well-Known Member
My top 5
1. Joe Montana
2. Tom Brady
3. Peyton Manning
4. Terry Bradshaw
5. Dan Marino

Honorable Mention
Brett Favre
Drew Brees
Aaron Rodgers(I expect him to one day be in the top 5)
Eli Manning (more clutch than his brother but Peyton is far and away the best regular season QB of all time.)
Bart Starr
Joe Namath
Roger Staubach
John Elway

Future candidates?
Andrew Luck
RG3
Colin Kaepernick
Joe Flacco
Tim Tebow.........ok kidding there.
 
rsoxguy

rsoxguy

Well-Known Member
Dan "isn't faithful to his wife" Marino.
It's sometimes hard to separate the personal from the professional, but he was a great player in his time.
 
captainkidd

captainkidd

Well-Known Member
jw24 said:
Being a Giants fan, I would say Eli Manning considering he upset the previously undefeated Patriots and was the king of 4th quarter comebacks during the season he won his second. But in all seriousness, I'd go with Joe Montana simply because he was clutch and delivered when it mattered the most.
Click to expand...

Oh come on......Eli Manning????????
 
Z

Zman-ks

Well-Known Member
MOXOMUMD said:
Dan "Laces Out" Marino
75.gif
Click to expand...

LOL...he was a kicker right? :P
 
MOXOMUMD

MOXOMUMD

Well-Known Member
I'm from NE Ohio. The Browns don't know what a great QB is. That's why I'm a Steelers fan but their QB's have had personal problems too.
Another example, Joe Namath. Good in his day but look at him now.
 
PUSH

PUSH

Well-Known Member
Hrudey3032 said:
Future candidates?
Andrew Luck
RG3
Colin Kaepernick
Joe Flacco
Tim Tebow.........ok kidding there.
Click to expand...

Luck- I agree
RG3- Injury is a concern, those QBs aren't used to last
Kaepernick- Again, they are being used to dangerously
Flacco- Don't think he'll ever get to top 10 all-time, hasn't had the great regular seasons
Tebow- The best ever. ;)
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom