Greatest QB of All-Time?

[captainkidd]

No offense to Ravens fans (and not just because they kicked my beloved Patriots behinds last year), but I don't see Flaaco going down as one of the greats. He had an amazing playoff run, but he's barely in top half of QB's in the league during the rest of his career.

As far as smartest QB, Brady and Manning (Peyton) are the 2 smartest to ever play the game. And they're both ridiculously dedicated.

 

[jw24]

Oh come on......Eli Manning????????

Be grateful no one said Tony Romo! Montana is better than Eli without a doubt. I'm just saying Eli has a case. Maybe you don't think he has one but let's agree to disagree.

 

[StarWarsGirl]

Joe Flacco


Okay, he's a good QB, maybe not the greatest ever. Who the greatest is...I've not a clue.

 

[StarWarsGirl]

No offense to Ravens fans (and not just because they kicked my beloved Patriots behinds last year), but I don't see Flaaco going down as one of the greats. He had an amazing playoff run, but he's barely in top half of QB's in the league during the rest of his career.

As far as smartest QB, Brady and Manning (Peyton) are the 2 smartest to ever play the game. And they're both ridiculously dedicated.

What?! How could you say that? Why, he is the greatest QB ever!!!! How dare you insult my beloved Flacco!

Okay, I'm just messing with you as usual. Flacco still has a lot of years with which to prove himself. So we'll see (I believe you and I had this conversation about not doubting the Ravens BEFORE we won the Super Bowl. Ha. Haha. Hahahaha (commence evil laugh). But I don't see him going down as one of the greats either. Though he did beat Tom Brady. Did you see that? Brady was crying. My uncle even froze the shot on his TV and made it his computer wallpaper.

 

[Dad 2 M & M]

Montana.

He was just so calm and collected. Joe Cool. Although he's still probably sending Jerry Rice Christmas cards with a stack of 100's in it signed "Thanks again for making me the best ever".

Maybe...might remind my homie that he had two rings BEFORE Jerry Rice was drafted....Rice may have pushed him to the top, lord knows Jerry put Steve Young in the conversation..

 

[captainkidd]

What?! How could you say that? Why, he is the greatest QB ever!!!! How dare you insult my beloved Flacco!

Okay, I'm just messing with you as usual. Flacco still has a lot of years with which to prove himself. So we'll see (I believe you and I had this conversation about not doubting the Ravens BEFORE we won the Super Bowl. Ha. Haha. Hahahaha (commence evil laugh). But I don't see him going down as one of the greats either. Though he did beat Tom Brady. Did you see that? Brady was crying. My uncle even froze the shot on his TV and made it his computer wallpaper.

Flaaco didn't beat Brady. The Ravens defense did. Brady has had really bad luck over the past few years. Their defense choked against the Giants in the Super Bowl. Then, his receivers choked (or were injured) against the Giants in the SB. He lost Gronkowski and Edelmen for the AFC Title Game.

 

[NYwdwfan]

Maybe...might remind my homie that he had two rings BEFORE Jerry Rice was drafted....Rice may have pushed him to the top, lord knows Jerry put Steve Young in the conversation..

He was (IMO) without a doubt top 10 without Rice. But best QB ever...and in the conversation for best PLAYER ever...came with Rice.

You ever watch those countdown shows on the NFL network? I get sucked into each and every one.

 

[GeoDonJac34]

Greatest state to put out QBS ?
PA. George Blanda, Johnny Unitas, Joe Montana, Joe Namath, Jim Kelly, Dan Marino, Matt Schaub, Matt Ryan, Rich Gannon. Six of 23 Hall of Fame QBS from Pa. Not too shabby.