We ALWAYS stayed at Pop. In the past few years the only deviations from Pop were AKL (got a great deal for my birthday in January) and sometimes POR. However, this past trip may have been our last trip to Pop for a while if we can afford to go moderate.
Mind you, we go a lot and really don't care to look at the "maintenance" issues unless they're blatant. And boy were they blatant. The wallpaper in the bathrooms were in disrepair somewhat, and I forget what my dad mentioned but he wasn't happy either. It's certainly starting to show its age.
The food court? I'm still mourning the loss of my amazing chicken penne alfredo. That was a shock to me as we got there late on a Friday night and I had no idea what to eat (we opted for a large pizza). Anyway, the one good thing they do offer is at breakfast, which is the biscuits and gravy with eggs. The new menu is all a matter of taste, but I'm not a fan of the new options.
I will say that I love the bus transportation for Pop. They don't share with any other hotels and we never have to wait too long. Pop is also pretty centrally located and get to the parks quickly, especially DHS.
Overall, it really is better than what I have said lol. I just think the time has come for us to move on. But I'm sure you'll have fun. The decor all around the resort is great, the pools are great, etc. But like I said, we may have outgrown it and there's no way we'll ever go back to the All Stars. Maybe we'll be able to do AoA (when the Little Mermaid section is actually available). But until then, it's moderate resorts all the way for us. We're giving CSR another try in a couple of weeks
Have fun!