You know what also worked, giving guests the next available time and having a clock at each kiosk saying when the next available time was. Then... get this... you could actually return any time after the original opening window.
There is absolutely no way to look at this as it is currently as an improvement. It won't be an improvement until you can get it on your smart phone, at which point it will save guests from trekking around the park, but will otherwise still be less convenient.
If you want this to be an improvement for
all guests while still prioritizing on-site guests, here's how you do it:
- On-site guests get advanced access to 1 attraction per day, unless they choice the Magic Kingdom, then they get 2 attractions per day.
- On-site Fastpass+ distribution includes all current Fastpass+ attractions, including parade viewing and fireworks viewing
- On-site Fastpass+ distribution is restricted to 50% of total Fastpass+ capacity at legacy Fastpass attractions
- Offsite guests cannot access Fastpass+ at new Fastpass+ attractions, parade viewing, and fireworks viewing
- Day of, guests will get access to Fastpass based on the legacy Fastpass distribution rules. On-site guests can modify their advanced selection under the current rules for modification.
- All of these "transactions" should be able to be done with a smart phone where you can define the individuals that you're traveling with and make Fastpass selections for all of them at once for the next available Fastpass time or the scheduled time you choice if you're modifying a Fastpass+ reservation.