You saying what you think should occur not what does. Fact is that Epcot closes at 9pm these days this event occurs, and it is not because this event is going on. Therefore this effects Epcot ticket holder 0% in the real world. Nobody is losing on this event. If you want it buy it, if not then don't. If you think the ones buying it are losing then again that effects you 0% so why would you possibly care.
Your opinion about the holiday parties do not seem to be shared by most, they are wildly popular with guest. You seem to be in the minority in you views on them. How can you explain their popularity if they are so "bad" for guest.....oh wait let me guess....they just don't know any better right....but you do....right?
The sad thing about guests is that they're easy to please. This means that TDO can get away with the minimal level of effort, and still turn around and crow about how "guest satisfaction rates have never been higher!"
It's not a hard question. If I asked the average guest, hey, would you rather pay $300 for the privilege of seeing the Christmas parade tonight, or would you rather the park stay open til midnight and you can see the parade for free? If anyone answers that they'd rather pay $300, they're insane. So yes, I do know better on this point.
Similarly, if a family of random guests is shown the Main Street Electrical Parade (which is missing several floats, depending on the night you see it), they may crow about how magical and wonderful it is, despite the fact that it's over 40 years old, poorly maintained and doesn't feature a character created after 1977. However, if a brand new, cutting edge light parade premiered with breathtaking floats covering Snow White to Frozen, they would be even MORE impressed. So which is better? MSEP or a brand new incredible parade? The answer is easy: brand new incredible parade. Guests are happy with both - that doesn't mean they're equal options.
I could go on, but suffice to say guest popularity doesn't equal quality. Guests love the Beauty and the Beast show at DHS - it's 20+ years old and is about as community theater as it gets. It should be replaced with a better show, despite its popularity. They'd love a better show even more.
Guests love Be Our Guest restaurant - they'd love a thrilling Beauty and the Beast ride even more. Guests love the Tangled potties with their lush theming - they'd love a lushly themed Tangled ride even more. Guests love Pirates of the Caribbean - they'd love it even more if all the animatronics worked.
Guests love Expedition Everest, but they'd love it more if the Yeti moved like it's supposed to. Guests love Figment, but they'd love him more if his ride wasn't such a half-assed shadow of its former self.
Guests love paying out the nose for Halloween and Christmas parties, but they'd love getting to experience them at no extra cost even more. This isn't a hard game to play, and sadly, you can play it all over WDW these days.
Who knows about the food portion or drink sizes, your conjecture is just that. Disney is not known for small food portions, if anything they stuff you on the DDP. Time will tell. I certainly hope I can buy more drinks.
I'm not going to argue MM with you, again your conjecture is just that. You don't know what you don't know....your guess are as valid as anybody else's but guess they are non the less.
I hope WDW continues to give me the option as a guest to pay for things that I want, or not too if I do not want them. Again it's how Walt opened DL and it seem to be a pretty successful business model.
The food/drink portions thing is conjecture, so it's a wait and see situation. The MM+ stuff isn't conjecture, but since this is the internet, I have no way of proving it. Believe me or don't, but there's a reason this is the second high priced specialty dining event introduced at Epcot in the past couple months. And there will be more high priced hard ticket things coming - new and exciting ways to squeeze extra dollars out of guest pockets to make their numbers look better than they actually are.
For the record, I'm not trying to be mean-spirited or to jump on you - but you should know that your visions of TDO/WDW being so altruistic are far from the truth. Their goal is to give you as little as possible for as much money as you're willing to hand them, nothing more - it's an undeniable pattern in almost every aspect of the resort's operations.