Dumbo v Bambi

[El_Chupacabra]

which do you prefer for the following categories:


Title-
Story-
Animation-
Ending-
Dialogue-
Supporting Animals-

 

[Pongo]

which do you prefer for the following categories:


Title-
Story-
Animation-
Ending-
Dialogue-
Supporting Animals-

:lol: This is a VERY random thread. Go figure.

Title- Either. They're bother just the names of the main character.
Story- Bambi
Animation- Bambi. By far.
Ending- Dumbo
Dialogue- Bambi. I like the fact that there's hardly any.
Supporting Animals- Bambi.

I guess I like Bambi more :lol:

 

[S.E.A.]

Title- Both, seriosly, how can you compare names of an elephant and a deer?
Story- Bambi...you know a story is good when it traumatizes millions of kids across the globe.
Animation- Bambi... you all know why.
Ending- Dumbo, because it was happy and cute.
Dialogue- Bambi, becasue there was none and it didn't need it.
Supporting Animals- Dumbo, those crows...that mouse...those elephants...

There's a reason why Bambi is part of the platinum line and Dumbo isn't.

 

[pluto77]

Interesting, I just brought both of these DVDs recently :lol:

Title: Both
Story: Bambi
Animation: Bambi
Ending: Bambi
Dialogue: Bambi, I also like the fact that there isn't much, the movie only has around 1000 words in the whole thing, maybe even less, although in Dumbo, the main character doesn't speak at all, I love both these, I think it makes it even better that there's not so much dialogue
Supporting Animals: Hard one... but I'll go with Bambi because thumper is so cool

Sorry Dumbo... Bambi won my vote this round

 

[The Mak]

Wrong forum for this thread.

 

[CAPTAIN HOOK]

Bambi is just so superior to Dumbo in every aspect

 

[Pumbas Nakasak]

Is that the sirens I hear of the thread police????:lookaroun

There both crap, sentimental dross, animals are food people not characters.

 

[El_Chupacabra]

animals are food people not characters.

ok wow


i totally disagree but i would say that bambi would win too cause i was thinking about it and Dumbo is a classic but not that good

 

[e4ymod]

Bambi because Flower is so cute and shy Hehe

 

[Connor002]

Bambi because Flower is so cute and shy Hehe

Now who does that sound like...

 

[e4ymod]

Now who does that sound like...

I don't know what you're talking about :lookaroun

 

[tigsmom]

I don't like either movie.

 

[Connor002]

Title- Bambi still sounds better than Dumbo, but I believe it comes from the feminine Italian name "Bambai" or something similar, which would hold connotations more related to romance and beauty...

Story- Both are on the same level for the most part...

Animation- Bambi, hands down; Dumbo is a cartoon, Bambi is a trip through a work of art.

Ending- Both are along the same level...

Dialog- Bambi, simply for its' lack of much dialog to distract for the story's focus of nature.

Supporting Animals-Well, I'd say Bambi again...

 

[Brett]

Story- I enjoy Dumbo's story more. It's about believing in yourself.
Animation- Bambi. Not many Disney movies can touch the animation in Bambi. Masterpiece.
Ending- Once again, I gotta give the nod to Dumbo. It's just so happy.
Dialog- Even. Bambi's lack of dialog works so well for the movie, but Dumbo's dialog works for it perfectly as well.
Supporting Animals- Bambi wins but Timothy the Mouse is one of the all time great secondary characters.

I believe Bambi sits on a different plateau than Dumbo. Bambi is one of Walt's pure creations of art and I believe Dumbo was more of just a great story. Both great, but in the end, I can't find many movies peroid that I enjoy more than Dumbo.

 

[DDuckFan130]

Dumbo is better than Bambi. The end

 

[nighttimewisher]

I think Dumbo is sadder but they may just be because i have seen the sad scene in Bambi too many times.

 

[scorp111]

:lookaroun Is this going to be a pay per view event on cable??


Bambi definitely wins in my book.

Thumper is the best!