I actually agree with this. Like the newer hotels, it's very "hit and miss". .
I like the new attraction concept personally, but they seem to be so focused on immersion that one could forget they're at sea. The whole point of a cruise is to be at sea, something the other ships embraced perfectly.
In the presentation, only the rooms and upper deck showed off the sea. Everything else was walled off rooms, for the most part, with controlled lighting. I might let the people with dollars to waste buy this while I enjoy the Dream or Fantasy.
Cons for me: no mention of virtual portholes for inside rooms, no Animator's Palate, pools look small for a ship that will have more passengers than previous ships, interior seems closed off and dark or covered in screens. I bet the new attraction will pull longer waits than the Aquaduck
Pros: new attraction, adult pool area with an infinity pool, 1923, two new shows.