Just to add... None of this changes the fact that, in order to experience the new attraction, you have to wake up early, which is the thing that people complain about the most. Waking up early will ALWAYS be an advantage, whether it's waking up to book something on your phone, waking up to go stand in a line, waking up to go get a paper FastPass ticket, waking up 60 days before your trip to book something from your computer, etc.
ETA: And to reiterate your point, once we're talking about 3 hour wait times, we're not just talking about what's efficient or convenient or fair. We're talking about basic human needs like food, drink, and bathrooms. The only people who want this are childless "Disney adults."
What the heck? We are happy, childless adults and were so before it became a millennial thing. I keep seeing this on here lately thrown about as some kind of insult.
We don't want a lottery. We want resort perks! We don't care about what's fair!