Tom
Beta Return
If you've ever had a kitchen remodeled or even just a sink fixed after a slow leak that caused even a minor amount of mold or rotten wood, you might also have seen what looked like this "mass demolition," but with the final product still looking like a kitchen and in more or less the same space, only with new fixtures, appliances, and cabinets, maybe even new tile or linoleum. Maybe even a wall torn out, to adjoin it to the breakfast nook, for a more open space. But still a kitchen. Still shoe horned into the existing outside structure and foot print.
So, depending on what you might call an "overlay," this may or may not qualify -- and it may not mean anything more that a remodel to an existing show building. A "mass destruction" would be more like what happened to Horizons -- tearing down the whole building and starting again.
This, so far, seems to be more like a re-model, using the existing building, than "starting from the ground up." Similar to "Extreme Makeover, Home Edition," when they do a nice remodel, versus some episodes where they completely tear down the whole building and build a whole new one.
Don't get me wrong. It may still be a nice ride (though still not appropriate for EPCOT -- because of World Showcase's mission), but it is still a kitchen, it seems. It is still a dark ride that appears to be shoehorned into the existing show building. May be OK, even nice. Maybe (or maybe not) "an overlay." But not "mass demolition'' either.
By day, I'm a commercial construction manager. I just finished a 2-year project wherein we gutted half of a hospital down to bare concrete and built-out completely new facilities in the shell spaces. It was considered a "remodel" only by Building Permit definition - but it was certainly "mass demolition" and a complete interior re-build. I stand by my assessment.
Well the budget we heard was $75 mil. Consider that it will be using the same ride system it's not going to be a cheap overlay. I would expect several Mine Train style animatronics and hopefully some halfway decent show scenes. I think if this ride was being put in Fantasyland we would all be thrilled.
If they're leaving the ride system, that saves a TON of money. They have the molds to produce the new boats back in Central Shops, so that's a minor cost, relatively speaking.
So, the $75M should go pretty far toward the mass demolition we're seeing, and re-building of all the sets. And when the "insiders" hear these budget numbers, who's to say they're not just hearing construction costs. The costs for AAs and ride systems may be tracked completely separately, or not included in the numbers that slip through loose lips.
I agree that it will likely be a very nice Fantasyland ride. Maybe it should replace Small World, and move Small World dolls to Norway and dress them all as trolls and frozen dolls.