Disney (and others) at the Box Office - Current State of Affairs

Agent H

Active Member
The reason all of this is happening is because we live in the era of the terminally online media grifter who complains about everything being “woke” for clicks they essentially brainwash otherwise good decent people into being the same way
I would like to add that for anyone looking for a particularly good mental defense against this type of thing or just to watch media grifters get figuratively torn to shreds I would recommend the birdmans exposing the grift on YouTube (no I am not shilling for him)
 

Dranth

Well-Known Member
Perfectly said… I feel Social Media has done real harm to our society…. I choose not participate in any of it… it is better for my mental health
Same.

Off topic I know but, there have been multiple studies now showing social media along the lines of Facebook, X, TikTok, etc. have a negative impact on mental health and the more you consume, the worse it gets. Interestingly, though not surprising, there are also studies that show that excessive consumption actually decreases your cognitive abilities. Namely attention span and critical thinking.

Might explain why so many just react with no real thought whenever they hear/see/read something they don't immediately agree with.

To try and tie it back to Disney movies and the ongoing discussion, this whole thing with Mackie looks a lot like people overreacting. If the movie is good most people won't care or even remember. Personally, I don't think it looks great, but I hope I am wrong on that count.
 

LittleBuford

Well-Known Member
I agree. But you know as well as I that isn't always going to happen.
I don’t agree. Perhaps I’m being naive, but I really do think we can and should work to reverse the normalisation of vitriol and incivility that we have all witnessed this past decade or so.

So again, why is what I'm saying so controversial to you and a few others?
I don’t find what you’re saying at all controversial. I just happen not to agree with it. From my perspective, it isn’t necessary and wouldn’t actually fix the issue, because those looking to agitate will always find a way (recall the vitriol directed at Halle Bailey, who never set a foot wrong in any of her interviews). Things will only change when decorum once again becomes valued in public discourse. It wasn’t all that long ago that it was.
 

Agent H

Active Member
Same.

Off topic I know but, there have been multiple studies now showing social media along the lines of Facebook, X, TikTok, etc. have a negative impact on mental health and the more you consume, the worse it gets. Interestingly, though not surprising, there are also studies that show that excessive consumption actually decreases your cognitive abilities. Namely attention span and critical thinking.

Might explain why so many just react with no real thought whenever they hear/see/read something they don't immediately agree with.

To try and tie it back to Disney movies and the ongoing discussion, this whole thing with Mackie looks a lot like people overreacting. If the movie is good most people won't care or even remember. Personally, I don't think it looks great, but I hope I am wrong on that count.
TikTok I think is especially bad if you spend too much time on it because it’s especially short videos the lesson here everything especially social media in moderation
 

Agent H

Active Member
TikTok I think is especially bad if you spend too much time on it because it’s especially short videos the lesson here everything especially social media in moderation
And with that in mind I’m going to take my own advice to heart and try to stay off these forums for a few hours ta ta for now agent h is out peace!
 

TP2000

Well-Known Member
Speaking for myself, I don’t care what they say but I believe they have a right to express their opinions without their words being misquoted and twisted out of shape by people with malicious intent.

But it's not 1965 and we aren't reading about this in a supermarket tabloid. It's 2025 and the entire planet has instant access on their phones to a clear HD video of Mr. Mackie coherently stating his opinion in English.

No misquotes or twisted context is required, nor really possible, when you have the actual HD video of Mr. Mackie's statement to the media available instantly to anyone on the planet.



That’s what happened with Zegler and it’s what’s happening with Mackie. They said nothing to provoke a “blow-up” and don’t deserve to have their opinions censored by corporate.

Apparently they both did say things, at least once (several times in the case of Miss Zegler) that caused a "blow-up". If there wasn't a blow-up, we wouldn't be talking about it here.

You may not agree that it's deserving of a blow-up, or you may agree strongly with Mr. Mackie that Captain America doesn't represent the actual country called "America". But enough people disagreed that it actually caused a blow-up.
 
Last edited:

Disney Irish

Premium Member
Celebrities are sent out to promote their film. They are suppose to be trained by PR to stay on script. When they screw up the script or the script is poorly worded, people instantly jump on it. Some are really good at handling these PR interviews and others like Zegler sound like morons when they didn't study their talking points.
You're making the assumption that in this case Mackie wasn't PR trained and doesn't stay on script, both of which doesn't appear to be the case.

Also as has been pointed out numerous times now, people are jumping all over a 10 second partial response clip from a larger response, ie its taken out of context.

Reasonable people can disagree about the wording, but as has been shown this same wording has been used to describe the character many many times, including by the previous actor.
 
Last edited:

erasure fan1

Well-Known Member
No I don't. You have spoken about getting past absolutes, except that is what you are doing now.
That was intentional because the responses I was getting. When the responses were I don't want a corporate canned response or limiting their right to express themselves. Yea, not what I said, at all. So just because I said a little PR training isn't a bad idea and I'm met with, their free speech shouldn't be taken away ,and statements like I just said. That's why I said it, to try and get a better response.
Are people so fragile today that they can't handle that a movie character from the comics isn't representing just a single nation but all people? No amount of rewording is going to change this faux outrage
Absolutely. Did you not think when you heard the clip, oh man, this is going to blow up? I know I did. You are telling me that he thinks cap doesn't represent one single nation. So I'm guessing, same as you, that if that's what is meant, he also thinks any person can look up to captain America. I don't think it's taking away anything from a personal standpoint, it's right in line with what we know. But it's a bit hard to say how he should rephrase it when you or I really don't actually know what he thinks. But the overall point is, maybe there's a better way to phrase it that does keep it his personal feelings. There's multiple ways to say things to get a feeling across. So just because he shifts how he says it, doesn't mean the meaning has to be different.
I just happen not to agree with it. From my perspective, it isn’t necessary and wouldn’t actually fix the issue, because those looking to agitate will always find a way
Fair enough. For me I personally don't not try things because I think they won't work. I try it, and if it doesn't work, try something new. Maybe I'm just more optimistic. Haters gonna hate, just as the sun shall rise. So do you think if he left off just the "and I don’t think the term ‘America’ should be one of those" we'd be having this conversation at all? I think we aren't, it's not a blip on anyone's radar.
 

Disney Irish

Premium Member
That was intentional because the responses I was getting. When the responses were I don't want a corporate canned response or limiting their right to express themselves. Yea, not what I said, at all. So just because I said a little PR training isn't a bad idea and I'm met with, their free speech shouldn't be taken away ,and statements like I just said. That's why I said it, to try and get a better response.
Well maybe change the discourse then if you're not getting the responses you think you should be getting; instead you're doing the very thing that you're accusing others of. Or maybe better yet realize that your stance is just not going agreed upon by the others here, so no reason to double down and just start doing the very thing you accuse them of.

Also its fairly clear Mackie has a lot of PR training. Just because its not worded the way you think it should doesn't mean he's not had PR training or that he doesn't have a PR team around him.

Absolutely. Did you not think when you heard the clip, oh man, this is going to blow up? I know I did. You are telling me that he thinks cap doesn't represent one single nation. So I'm guessing, same as you, that if that's what is meant, he also thinks any person can look up to captain America. I don't think it's taking away anything from a personal standpoint, it's right in line with what we know. But it's a bit hard to say how he should rephrase it when you or I really don't actually know what he thinks. But the overall point is, maybe there's a better way to phrase it that does keep it his personal feelings. There's multiple ways to say things to get a feeling across. So just because he shifts how he says it, doesn't mean the meaning has to be different.
No, I actually thought I heard it before by others so didn't think it was going to be a big deal. But then I remembered where I heard it before when I read that Forbes article I posted, Chris Evans basically said the exact same thing when he was asked the same question when playing the role. And yet no one jumped all over him when he said it. Heck as provided example here, Cap himself said it at various times in the comics. So this is not like some foreign stance in relation to this character. And as pointed out even in the MCU Cap goes against "America", its the whole basis for Civil War.

So yeah all these people outraged need to get a bit of perspective here. They don't even understand the character in which they are outraged over.
 

LittleBuford

Well-Known Member
So do you think if he left off just the "and I don’t think the term ‘America’ should be one of those" we'd be having this conversation at all?
No, I don't. It's true that his words provided the agitators with a perfect vehicle, though I believe they would have found another, perhaps less effective, pretext to cast their aspersions anyway. You are right that media training would probably result in fewer incidents of this type, but I think it's the actors themselves who should decide whether to receive such training. I personally don't believe it would address the root of the problem.
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom