If you haven't looked already check out the revised beverage packages w/RCI. We did the premium and found it very worthwhile.It is out of "normal" vacation range for us as well.
One of the factors is also their choice of ports. If there were more sailings out of NYC or Bayonne during times when we could go, then maybe. But having to add airfare to the cost of the cruise makes it a lot more expensive.
I can get a 6 day / 5 night sailing on RC out of Bayonne to Bermuda for the second week in April for $495 pp inside stateroom right now. That value spread gets larger and larger.
-dave
Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.