Yesterday I booked Coronado for March 16-23. Although it's not my favorite Moderate... I highly disagree with those who think it's noisy... We've stayed there three times before and one of the things we liked about it is how quiet it is. It's not a 'kid resort.' It's an older crowd than the All Stars and Pop Century. The main pool area is busy, but the room buildings and other pools are quiet and a nice place for a couple or some friends to talk at night.
I was spoiled forever with DVC (until we had to sell it) and that's why I was kind of depressed that we "had" to stay at a Moderate... Ironically, this thread has made me more supportive of Coronado. When I think back, I remember far more good things than bad things. Also, it has queen beds and a good TV. It's a great resort... all things considered.
Oh, and to the OP: I've stayed at WL Villas as well... and though it is beautiful, for some reason I am just not that into the MK area resorts. I'd choose the cost savings of a moderate resort and push some of that money toward a few great meals.