Continuity error on smuggler’s run?

mergatroid

Well-Known Member
Hodor, Hondo, Honda......it doesn't matter. What matters is not one of the following 3 appropriate characters addresses us:

No Lando
No Solo
No Chewey


Millennium Falcon = Lando, Solo and/or Chewey. Such a basic Star Wars formula to understand.

Well I'm pretty sure it does to him :rolleyes:

Personally I'm good with Hondo and saw Chewie on the way in and heard him when we 'took off'. I understand that some want the original characters in the ride like yourself, what can I say though as they decided not to go with them.
 

FoozieBear

Well-Known Member
Hodor, Hondo, Honda......it doesn't matter. What matters is not one of the following 3 appropriate characters addresses us:

No Lando
No Solo
No Chewey


Millennium Falcon = Lando, Solo and/or Chewey. Such a basic Star Wars formula to understand.

1. If you were to get Harrison Ford on board to do Han Solo, how would that even make sense in this context? Han Solo has been dead for quite a while, and the land you're in takes place after his death.
2. Why tie it to a specific character/actor when you can use characters at your disposal to create new stories and evolve the land without affecting the cinematic canon?
3. You can't seriously be suggesting that you want Chewbacca the Wookie to address you before your mission. Perhaps you're already fluent in the dialect, I imagine most people left their Wookie dictionaries back in their hotel room.
 

Mickeyboof

Well-Known Member
1. If you were to get Harrison Ford on board to do Han Solo, how would that even make sense in this context? Han Solo has been dead for quite a while, and the land you're in takes place after his death.
2. Why tie it to a specific character/actor when you can use characters at your disposal to create new stories and evolve the land without affecting the cinematic canon?
3. You can't seriously be suggesting that you want Chewbacca the Wookie to address you before your mission. Perhaps you're already fluent in the dialect, I imagine most people left their Wookie dictionaries back in their hotel room.

It’s a theme park land.

Also, technically everyone is dead. This was a long, long time ago remember?
 

HongKongFu

Well-Known Member
3. You can't seriously be suggesting that you want Chewbacca the Wookie to address you before your mission.


Holy Guacamole!

I am 100% serious. If the script were done properly we would know damn well what's going on by a Chewie body movement and gesters, voice accentuations, facial displays.

In the movies are you telling me you had no idea what Chewey was up to or feeling.

All it would take is proper context and to really make things easy another character could chime in via video(which I don't prefer)or even a live character could add to the dialogue(which I also don't prefer).
 

Mickeyboof

Well-Known Member
Holy Guacamole!

I am 100% serious. If the script were done properly we would know damn well what's going on by a Chewie body movement and gesters, voice accentuations, facial displays.

In the movies are you telling me you had no idea what Chewey was up to or feeling.

All it would take is proper context and to really make things easy another character could chime in via video(which I don't prefer)or even a live character could add to the dialogue(which I also don't prefer).

Both Hondo and an AA Chewie would be perfect for the cause
 

THE 1HAPPY HAUNT

Well-Known Member
I thought this at first too, but the Falcon is parked out front for refueling and diagnostics checks (if you stick around for awhile you'll see and hear system checks performed) and then brought around back to the loading bay. Without it appearing in the pre-show video, it would not make sense how we board it through an airport-style boarding bridge and take off out of an enclosed hangar.

of course, this doesn't explain why it is back out front after you ride, but...
It still does not make sense we board it that way when no one, in any of the films in the HISTORY OF STAR WARS has ever boarded the falon through a jetway style connection. it has always been the ramp, and Luke through the top hatch in Empire. Never has it even been hinted that the falon has a side area you could "attach" that opens up because that does not make sense. the falcon is a small ship meant to be entered from the ramp or the top hatch if it was docked to a larger ship, never the side. Call me a nitpicker you all want but that is a major detail that has canoical relevance that disney ignored for the purpose of their ride that ruins the immersion of actually stepping on the falcon for me and selling me the experience that i just boarded the real millenium falcon which was their goal.
 

THE 1HAPPY HAUNT

Well-Known Member
Holy Guacamole!

I am 100% serious. If the script were done properly we would know damn well what's going on by a Chewie body movement and gesters, voice accentuations, facial displays.

In the movies are you telling me you had no idea what Chewey was up to or feeling.

All it would take is proper context and to really make things easy another character could chime in via video(which I don't prefer)or even a live character could add to the dialogue(which I also don't prefer).
you could have chewie talk to the crowd while the droid in the same room translates what he is saying on the screen and maybe have a siri like voice translate it after he is done speaking.
 

Tom Morrow

Well-Known Member
It still does not make sense we board it that way when no one, in any of the films in the HISTORY OF STAR WARS has ever boarded the falon through a jetway style connection. it has always been the ramp, and Luke through the top hatch in Empire. Never has it even been hinted that the falon has a side area you could "attach" that opens up because that does not make sense. the falcon is a small ship meant to be entered from the ramp or the top hatch if it was docked to a larger ship, never the side. Call me a nitpicker you all want but that is a major detail that has canoical relevance that disney ignored for the purpose of their ride that ruins the immersion of actually stepping on the falcon for me and selling me the experience that i just boarded the real millenium falcon which was their goal.
I mean, this is totally true, but I can't think of any way they could move mass quantities of people into a full size Falcon and also have that Falcon be where people board the ride vehicles in a convincing way that allows for multiple cockpits. This is something I have no doubt that they thought about but had to compromise some continuity to make it work.
 

THE 1HAPPY HAUNT

Well-Known Member
I mean, this is totally true, but I can't think of any way they could move mass quantities of people into a full size Falcon and also have that Falcon be where people board the ride vehicles in a convincing way that allows for multiple cockpits. This is something I have no doubt that they thought about but had to compromise some continuity to make it work.
If hondo can magically add extra seats to the falcon without having to dismantle and rebuild the tiny cockpitt and be able to divert the controls for the main falcon guns to the cockpitt since in every movie the main guns are in their own gunner rooms with chairs(except for small short range guns Han used in Empire that were controled from his cockpitt console not the side, but the ones on the ride are meant to be the main falcon guns) then they could have had it where he put in a bigger temp ramp for easier mass entrance to the falcon. it could have been done. easily.
 

Tom Morrow

Well-Known Member
If hondo can magically add extra seats to the falcon without having to dismantle and rebuild the tiny cockpitt and be able to divert the controls for the main falcon guns to the cockpitt since in every movie the main guns are in their own gunner rooms with chairs(except for small short range guns Han used in Empire that were controled from his cockpitt console not the side, but the ones on the ride are meant to be the main falcon guns) then they could have had it where he put in a bigger temp ramp for easier mass entrance to the falcon. it could have been done. easily.
But how could you step into a full-size Falcon that has the cockpit carousel attached to it but also hidden so you don't see it when you board? You would have to step into a mock up of the back of the Falcon and a ramp, with most of the ship covered or hidden from view.

Like, I really think that, although it doesn't make much sense, I doubt this was a case of negligence or not caring and more of a compromise than anything.

That said, when I first stepped into the Falcon lounge area, it took me a second to realize what it was, because it sure didn't feel like I actually stepped onto a ship.
 

THE 1HAPPY HAUNT

Well-Known Member
But how could you step into a full-size Falcon that has the cockpit carousel attached to it but also hidden so you don't see it when you board? You would have to step into a mock up of the back of the Falcon and a ramp, with most of the ship covered or hidden from view.

Like, I really think that, although it doesn't make much sense, I doubt this was a case of negligence or not caring and more of a compromise than anything.

That said, when I first stepped into the Falcon lounge area, it took me a second to realize what it was, because it sure didn't feel like I actually stepped onto a ship.
you move the falcon inside the building and put a diff ship out front
 

Tom Morrow

Well-Known Member
you move the falcon inside the building and put a diff ship out front
I'm not sure if you're aware of how the ride works. There are four different rotating carousels holding multiple cockpits. After you see Hondo, you are sent to one of two Falcon "chess table" rooms. Each of these rooms has two of the four cockpit carousels attached to it via a hallway. After you are buckled into your cockpit, the doors close and your cockpit rotates to the next position, allowing for the next cockpit on the carousel to move from the unload spot to the load spot.

Not only would they have to have two Falcon mockups, you would not be able to see the whole thing, because they would have to disguise the fact that the cockpits are constantly being rotated out. So instead of having a full-size Falcon out front that we can see every single angle of and are free to take as many pictures as we want of, we would be limited to seeing a mockup of just the back of the ship. I'd rather just see the whole thing, it's a very impressive focal point in the land.
 

KINGLOUIS1993

Well-Known Member
Hodor, Hondo, Honda......it doesn't matter. What matters is not one of the following 3 appropriate characters addresses us:

No Lando
No Solo
No Chewey


Millennium Falcon = Lando, Solo and/or Chewey. Such a basic Star Wars formula to understand.

Because the whole concept of Galaxy's Edge is to be a new experience within the Star Wars Universe, somewhere different. They have gone with Hondo because it means they have more room to be creative with the storyline of the ride.
 

HongKongFu

Well-Known Member
Because the whole concept of Galaxy's Edge is to be a new experience within the Star Wars Universe, somewhere different. They have gone with Hondo because it means they have more room to be creative with the storyline of the ride.


Yes, I have known even well before my visits.

.....very poor decision to not use Vaders and Yodas
 

macefamily

Well-Known Member
I'm just trying to get my money's worth of entertainment and enjoy a movie-based ride. I like checking out the details and admiring the work that was put into the construction as well as enjoying the new technology used in developing this awesome ride. I'm sorry, but I don't get caught up in story lines for a fictional premise. I have way too much happening in my head during a day at the parks to contemplate that situation.
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom