Just putting my 2 cents in - all of the information provided is correct and the dinner pkg vs waiting in the stand-by line is a matter of choice. Here's my experience:
The first year we saw this, in 2000, it was standing room only, but still great. The following year, we got in line about 30 min early and got great seats. I'm not sure what the difference was since we went the same dates both years and had the same narrator (Phylicia Rashad!).
Last year, our last day at WDW was the day after Thanksgiving so since this was the first day of the CP, I bought the dinner package. We ate at the Biergarten 'cos it was closer to the theatre and we had never eaten there before. It's a good thing we had the pkg 'cos it was jammed to the gills in the American Gardens Theatre. Andy Garcia was the narrator in 2003 and also did a good job, but Phylicia Rashad is my favorite. We also bought the CD, which features her :xmas:
.