I'm a big planner, so of course before my stay at POFQ I was concerned about requesting "the best" location. I didn't pay for a water view room, so I knew not to request a water view room (which would be requesting a free upgrade).
I knew I wanted to be as close to the food court/bus stop as possible, so rather than requesting a specific building, I requested simply "close to food court and bus."
We checked in at around 11 p.m., two weary parents and two very sleepy kids ages 6 and 4. I was very disappointed when the front desk CM circled our room location on a resort map ... we were at the far end of Building 2, which looked pretty far away on the map. I resigned myself to a long walk with our kids and carry-ons (we arranged for our Disney's Magical Express luggage to be delivered the following morning).
I was very very pleasantly surprised that our walk from the front desk to the 3rd floor of the far wing of Building 2 took all of 2 minutes. Yes, our "far" room was 2 minutes to the lobby.
Later during our stay, I timed the walk from the farthest away room (at the very corner of Building 1 along the river) to the food court doors at 3 minutes 20 seconds.
All of this led me to the conclusion that room selection at POFQ really doesn't matter. The resort is so pleasantly compact that there's no such thing as an inconvenient room.
Are some rooms farther away than others? Of course. But the small size of the resort makes those distinctions pretty meaningless. At some WDW resorts, room location makes or breaks the stay ... but definitely not at POFQ.
If you put Oprah Winfrey, Bill Gates and the Queen of England in a room, Oprah would be the "poor" person in that room, even though, of course, she's definitely not poor. Same thing with POFQ rooms, in my opinion.