Thanks for the advice everyone! After discussing it with the fiance it looks like we have decided to do the Atlantis Aquaventure (it looks fun and hopefully worth the price!) on our one day in Nassau and then just bring or rent masks, snorkels, and fins for our day at Castaway Cay. It sounds like you don't have to do a guided tour for the snorkeling there, correct? We figure we definitely want to snorkel, but it will be nice to do it at our pace and have plenty of time for relaxing too.
Thanks again for everyone's input...is it October yet?!?!? haha!
Thanks again for everyone's input...is it October yet?!?!? haha!