So I had lunch with a friend today, and we came up with MCU rankings, as we talked about our excitement over Endgame. This was my list (the movies aren’t ranked in the individual categories, it’s just how I write them):
Top
- The Avengers
- Infinity War
- Thor: Ragnarok
- Black Panther
- Iron Man
- Guardians of the Galaxy
- Captain America: the Winter Soldier
Middle
- Ant-Man
- Ant-Man & the Wasp
- Captain America: the First Avenger
- Captain America: Civil War
- Captain Marvel
- GotG Vol. 2
- Iron Man 3
- Spider-Man: Homecoming
- Thor
Bottom (just because they’re in the bottom tier does not mean I think they’re bad- they’re better than Justice League & Suicide Squad, but they’re not as good as the other MCU films, IMO)
- Iron Man 2
- The Incredible Hulk
- Thor: the Dark World
- Doctor Strange
- Age of Ultron
Endgame has very big shoes to fill here. It’s the final chapter of a very long epic (the sequel to it begins with the new Spider-Man). And how it ends will probably shape our overall viewing of the series as a whole. Four examples:
- Harry Potter (book series): after 10 years and a lot of hype, Deathly Hallows was seen as a worthy end to the series. It offered a lot of closure for characters, and the characters had to work for and earn their happy endings- if they got one. War did not come without sacrifice, but we saw our heroes defeat evil and live to tell the tale. How does Endgame accomplish something similar? By letting the characters act in ways we have seen them act before. No moments that feel out of character. Tony Stark and Steve Rogers are both like Harry Potter- we have seen them sacrifice themselves for others.
- The Hunger Games (book series, and film series, because both endings were disappointing): This... this was not a good ending. We got more of the ‘War is hell’ mentality from the first two books, but the third book didn’t fit the tone of the first two. There were things I liked about it, but I know a lot of fans were disappointed by the ending. How does Endgame avoid this? It can start by repeating what we saw in Infinity War- the deaths all had meaning. It had been years and I still hate how Finnick was dispatched in like one sentence.
- Star Wars, original trilogy: I’m not here to bash Return of the Jedi, I like that movie. However, Empire Strikes Back was so great, that RotJ didn’t really stand a chance. There are a lot of good moments in that movie, but it just never reached the same highs as Empire. Honestly, this is what I’m a little worried about for Endgame. We’re going to see a time jump with the characters post snap (like the rebels post Cloud City). The characters will all be spread out again (if the Thor/Carol rumors are true). Possibly a gangster character.
- Game of Thrones (tv series, since the books are still being written): I know the last season hasn’t started yet, but the show and Endgame are in the same predicament. They both need to finish a story. They’ve both changed things from the source material, which makes some fans angry and some happy. And they’re both ending around the same time. And I am very curious to see how they compare to each other. GoT, I’m honestly guessing it will get the Mockingjay treatment- some fans are going to be very upset, but it fits the material. Endgame is probably going to be more like Harry Potter or Star Wars OT.