I think it has always been a bit of a misnomer to call AoA a value resort.
Yes, it is true that AoA doesn't have some of the things that typically are needed to categorize a resort as a moderate. For example, there is no actual sit down, table service restaurant at AoA. However, the Landscape of Flavors food court seems, by all accounts, to be absolutely amazing and something entirely different from just about anything called a food court anywhere else on property.
Also, AoA is much more themed to appeal to children, while the moderate resorts typically have a more "adult" theming with a bit more elegance. But to the audience they are trying to draw, including my family, that is a positive, not a negative.
AoA is definitely a cut above any other value resort on property, by a mile. If not a moderate, it should be put into a new category in between value and moderate.