To me, most of the Values are the same (oversized tacky themeing)...so my choice is based on familiarty and convenience. I mostly stay at the Pop Century since almost everyone thinks its the best of the Values. However, in March I stayed at All Star Movies. Yes the room was smaller and it often shares a bus, but my room was closer to the All Star Music bus stop than even a room at the All Star Music. Since I seemed to always travel at the peak time, the resorts weren't sharing and I never waited more than 5 minutes for a bus. That might have been good timing on my part though. So if I had to stay at an All Star resort again, I would choose Movies and request the Mighty Ducks Building...it took maybe two-three minutes to walk to the All Star Music Busses.