We stayed at POR for the first time during the 2nd week of August 2009. We had previously stayed at ASMo twice before, but felt it time to move up a notch for a little more room and a little more "mature" theming. Our daughters were 10 and 8 this time, so we kinda felt we'd outgrown the scenery of ASMo (it was great when they were younger).
Since we live in the deep South (near Charleston, SC), POR seemed like it would feel like home. I also read many wonderful reviews, but then would find the occasional not-so-great trip report. The worrying is natural, and I don't want to discount anyone's less-than-staisfactory experience, but with so many excellent reviews, I had a comfortable feeling that this was the right resort for us. We were not disappointed!
We stayed in Magnolia Terrace and were very close to a bus stop. Our room was clean, well-cared for, and the extra square-footage was a plus. Two vanities in the bath area was a real asset for four people to use as we dressed for breakfast ADRs. To be honest, we didn't spend that much time in the room, but the building was quiet and convenient. The food court wasn't too far away, and we got to enjoy the beautiful grounds when we walked there. Since POFQ is so close by, we took the boat (a bonus) there to eat a few meals in that food court too (another bonus). No complaints about the bus service--the buses were prompt and the resort seems more centrally located than AS, so the trips to the parks are quicker. To top it off, we surprised our daughters with a carriage ride reservation around the grounds one evening at dusk (another bonus not available too many other places). The main pool with the water slide was lots of fun, the quiet pools really are (quiet), and was I even able to quickly do some laundry one morning while my family slept in using the on-site facilities without having to wait for a washer or dryer. While we did not eat at Boatwright's (TS restaurant at POR), it's a nice option to have another restaurant to easily choose from at this resort.
I'm sure some have had problems during their stay at POR, but that's going to be true at any WDW resort. There are no guarantees. If the photos and descriptions of POR first attracted you to this resort, we think you'll be rewarded with a wonderful stay there.
BTW...our family agrees that we really want to stay there again.