I'm bored, so I'll post my thoughts.
@RMichael21
You brought back Spectromagic!
I enjoyed you decision to replace Fantasmic, and found your concept incredibly solid.
Your video was fun. Even though it's cliche slides and you used an online builder, you made good choices! It WORKED!
I enjoyed it. The only thing I'll say is that some of your slides were a bit wordy during the into especially, and that made me have to pause the video to read them all.
I loved the "intro" where you run through the segments.
I specifically tried to avoid "Magic Kingdom" characters with anticipation that HS is going to become the place where IP that isn't MK "fits", but that was a creative choice. Your's worked really well! It was a creative choice on my part to keep it something which would ONLY work at HS (or perhaps DCA). But, that being said, I loved your concept!
Slice of "wow"...what a great term! I'm stealing that, thank you!
I just wish you'd made an attempt to at least post a soundtrack. I understand you not wanting to attempt animating an entire show (trust me, I wish I hadn't either), but I'd love to know more about your concept.
And...that's what your presentation (for better and for worse) left me wanting...was more.
Great job! This will be a hard battle!
----------------------------------------
@jdmdisney99
Overall, and we are internet friends, so don't take this the wrong way. This was lackluster for you. In every sense of the word.
I'll start with the positives:
Your soundtrack was VERY well done, from your choices of music to your show pacing and timing. Well edited, and careful choices were made (though, I could go into an IP snit about how you used LOTR...but I won't).
That's...about it.
The mehs...
I certainly noticed you took the time to put in crowd noises and fireworks noises into your soundtrack. I toyed with the idea (creating a few sample drafts) and found that it was more of a distraction unless the animation was lifelike (which there was NO way I was going to create the 25k images needed for 30 fps for my vid) so I dropped it.
You didn't. And, in my opinion only, you should have. While at some times it works (like your finale) more often than not it distracts from the music. Something that would be ok, assuming you had decent animation on the video itself, but you didn't. A few less of them would have been a good thing.
Overall, your video was a wonderful attempt, but...really showed one of your weaknesses. It was just stale and boring. I had to force myself to watch it all the way through, and even then it was only the soundtrack that dragged me through it all.
All that being said I find a two things amusing.
1) We both chose Chinese Theater as opposed to replacing Fantasmic, as both our competitors did...
2) We largely did similar concepts in that it was a tribute to the movies, though my choices were newer films, yours were classic and endearing
None of this should be construed to mean I didn't like your concept, I did. Just giving constructive critique...cause, well, I'm bored...
And, it's hard to compare what you did to what Red did...because...
----------------------
@MonorailRed
You took this hands down I bow at your feet.
That show was amazing (yeah, I know I got to see the video before all you did because of my "haxxor" talents and all that...
The map was ugly, and should have been left out.
Your intro is nice and all, but I had real trouble understanding how it would tie into yoru show. Yeah, I get the flying paper (and nice animation on that later on btw), but...some overlay text would have been better, rather than the slide style you used, so I understood the story AS I was watching it, not after the fact.
You still don't have that "standard image size" thing down yet do you. Hint...it's under "canvas properties" <wink> Though, this was far less jumpier than your previous one.
Gonna say again, as I rewatch this for commentary, I truly enjoyed the story you chose...but, I'm a Disnerd, as are we all, so...that's a given. But, what I can't understand is the jump to Frozen? How does that fit into your larger "story"? Walt had nothing to do with that piece of...er...box office smash.
The Lion King part was REALLY well done.
Why do you like browns so much? Even your night sky is greenish brown...
Mulan gets a win, and I nearly missed the dragon...but saw it on the third viewing (yeah, I'm bored, see?)
Ok, you included Oz (which I think is a wholly underrated movie myself)...only briefly, nice intro to Over the Rainbow choice.
I absolutely adored the ending.
So...all that being said, I'm going to have to search for my major criticism...and since none of us (the other competitors) addressed it, it may be the one the Judge nails you (or any of us) on...
How is it forward thinking for what HS is going to become?
--------------------------
I think we all turned out fantastic work considering the time allowed and the restrictions of the challenge.
This is gonna be a tough one folks!
<tips his hat to everyone>