15 minutes left in the day, you rode Pirates and Haunted Mansion already, but you can choose between the two of them which one to go on again

[Walt Disney1955]

Okay, so I think it would be cruel to say you could only do one. Honestly, that's just torture. No matter the line ups there is never a day at Magic Kingdom where I haven't done BOTH rides. I've had a day where I missed Space Mountain or Jungle Cruise or such, but never these two. So you did them each once, but you can go on one more ride and you choose between the two of them. To me it is like asking between steak and lobster. And to be honest if I hadn't done either one of them all day my answer might change.

But if I did both already and could do one again.........................Haunted Mansion. Only because it is longer. But no matter what, when I pick one of these I always want the other.

 

[JIMINYCR]

It would be torture to decide between them. I could go either way and it might be decided by the line wait difference. Pirates might be my choice because Id be leaving the park singing Yo Ho Yo HO a Pirates Life for Me.

 

[Smiley/OCD]

UGH!! It’s like asking me which daughter I love more!! If I HAVE to pick, I’m gonna choose PotC, ONLY because I have a really hard time on the moving sidewalk, and I REFUSE to ask the CM’s to stop the omnimover to allow me to get on…BOTH rides are awesome!!

 

[Iris]

Not even an issue... Haunted Mansion

 

[Ricky Spanish]

Haunted Mansion.
Mrs Spanish and I renewed our vows in front of it last year during MNSSHP.

 

[NickMaio]

Pirates
I love that ride and the smell of bromine in the air

 

[WondersOfLife]

Uh.... You bet your booty I'm getting on Carousel of Progress or It's a Small World.

 

[Raxel7851]

It will always be HM, although it is close.

 

[SyracuseDisneyFan]

Haunted Mansion

 

[SaucyBoy]

I will always choose Haunted Mansion over that pathetically mediocre Pirates of the Caribbean. You can't drag me on Pirates unless you've got a great reason for why I need to subject myself to that torture.

 

[Walt Disney1955]

I will always choose Haunted Mansion over that pathetically mediocre Pirates of the Caribbean. You can't drag me on Pirates unless you've got a great reason for why I need to subject myself to that torture.

I'm curious. Why do you feel that way? Granted the Disneyland version of Pirates is better than WDW's, but it is still an exceptional ride.

 

[mf1972]

HM by a mile. although i like both rides, i hate the new auction scene in POTC.

 

[ohioguy]

Which one am I closest to? Otherwise, hard to make a decision on these two attractions.

 

[Cmdr_Crimson]

I can get a good two rides on the PeopleMover instead...

 

[NickMaio]

I can get a good two rides on the PeopleMover instead...

If it doesn't break down while you are on it.
Leaving you stranded for an hour waiting for CM's to walk you off.

 

[AndyS2992]

Haunted Mansion. WDW’s Pirates needs bulldozing and rebuilding from the ground up properly. Having ridden Paris’s versions of both, I’ve been spoilt. WDW’s versions of both pale in comparison.

 

[donaldtoo]

Pirates of the Caribbean, as it was the first of the two I ever rode at Disneyland back in the summer of ‘68, when I was almost 6, so I have a special place in my heart for even the WDW version. HM didn’t open at Disneyland ‘til August of ‘69…!!!

 

[Chef Mickey]

Haunted Mansion. WDW’s Pirates needs bulldozing and rebuilding from the ground up properly. Having ridden Paris’s versions of both, I’ve been spoilt. WDW’s versions of both pale in comparison.

I don't prefer the Paris version of either over WDW, particularly Haunted Mansion.

 

[WaluigiTime]

Haunted Mansion, now if it was Disneyland's Pirates it would be a harder choice.

 

[ppete1975]

I think I would pick Haunted mansion because its night time... so you enter and its dark and spooky outside and you leave and its dark and spooky... to me haunted is always best at night.
but if you could do pirates and jungle cruise......