this place is not overrated - it was underpriced.
Cellier only really took off when the dining plan came out.
Its as simple as people on the dining plan, trying to get the most $ value out of the meals. Many people loved saying they got a $30 Filet Mignon with their 39.99 a day meal plan.
I...
I like Liberty Tree- love the colonial theme. The meal isn't too sophisticated - but you have a few other ones that are. I wasn't a fan of crystal palace.
just go with the regular plan - with (2) Options
1) Pay out of pocket when they eat at non-signature. Save your credits for Signature dining (you dont have to be on Deluxe to eat there)
2) Pay out of pocket at the Signature TS places.
You can park or get a taxi to the Transportation center (TTC), and take the monorail or walk to the Polynesian, then head upstairs to Ohana - not a problem even if you are not a guest.
You should definitely try to make a reservation though.
Kona Cafe is best for breakfast IMO -
I would suggest Flying Fish over Coral Reef too.
There is also plenty of seafood options at better rated restaurants - just look through the menus.
I wouldn't do the Deluxe plan unless you are going to add more signature meals than just Le Cellier -
and I wouldn't do the DDP unless you so one signature meal per day.
boma is really good - but i hate the trek to the AKL unless I am going to AK park that day.
Kona cafe is great - and usually you can even get during busy times.
The Wave is really good too- if you appreciate healthy options like whole grain waffles, fresh fruit etc..
The classic debate, of those that can't handle some privlidge or benefit correctly- and people wanting to ban that for the everyone.
I enjoy having a beers of the world as I travel- but I have never tried to do them all- that's a bit too much.