Oh I would have totally done the same thing in the store you did if it was a meltdown like that. 100%. Thank God I never had to!! Though, as I said, DH did remove DS a few weeks ago from a restaurant. But we usually manage to see it coming and prevent the complete over the top meltdown. We have sticky moments, for sure, and they are embarrassing, but it's never lasted more than a few seconds where a well placed comment about a corner wouldn't suffice, or where we could say "You stop that right now or we're leaving and there will be no more fun things today". At least not in the grocery store. Like I said, the big ones for DS have been more about something feeling wrong and they are usually outside...like, he got upset once and I had to stand at an intersection for 45 minutes until he was ready to look both ways for cars. If the kids didn't look themselves, we didn't cross because I wasn't going to have them reliant on someone else for their safety...they had to learn to be safe on their own. So we just stood there for 45 minutes while he cried. I think he was only 4 then...and eventually we called daddy because he was so mad at ME that he wasn't going to do what I wanted and I was NOT going to give in and lose to a 4 year old. Mommy makes the rules. So we called daddy, he talked to DS, got him calmed down, and then DS looked both ways and we were on our way. I'm a choose your battles kind of mom...but when I choose one, I do not back down. We have never had too big of a problem in public venues because the kids wanted something and we said no. If we did, I don't remember them. My trick in the grocery store was to have them help. "Ok, mommy needs some of that pasta on the bottom shelf there...who wants to get a package for me and put it in the cart?" It normally kept them too occupied to be causing mayhem, and they knew if they threw a fit, it wasn't going to get them what they wanted and then there would be no TV, or dessert, or anything fun for the rest of the day. So that generally wasn't a big issue with us. There were times when they might whine about it, but never the meltdowns. (with the exception of DS, but not because he wants something...it's a panic response for him when something is scary.) We are working on the panic response now, and the anger when something happens that he wasn't expecting. But I know, from an outsider's perspective, they don't know DS...they can't see that he has these issues. It's not something you can tell by looking at him, so if he's having a meltdown, he just looks like a kid throwing a tantrum, and people tend to be really judgmental about that. Either people think I'm being a horrible mean mom because I'm standing at an intersection letting him cry, or they think I'm a lazy mom who doesn't want to punish her kid. Either way, they don't know what's going on, and I don't really care so much about their opinion...I do what works for us and what is healthier for my kid. I have to think about his safety first and not worry about what other people are thinking of ME. It's hard sometimes, as I'm sure you know since people were looking at you as you carried a screaming toddler out of the store like you were kidnapping her. But we have to do what's best for the child and not worry about that judgment because they aren't the ones who are responsible/liable for your kid. You did what was best for you guys, and sometimes there's not a lot of time to think about it...you know your kid and what works and what doesn't. What someone else did may not work with your child...Lord knows that my kids are night and day...what works for one won't work for the other because they are coming from a totally different perspective. We do what works.