The Spirited Back Nine ...

WDW1974

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
Spirited request:

My threads are a no-spoiler (or reasonable version) zone, so just like I won't be talking about tonight's decent, if VERY predictable Walking Dead episode, I'll request that no one uses the thread to blabber on about Interstellar and Big Hero 6.

I'll be seeing the former this week and the latter Thanksgiving week and I'd appreciate no plot comments or the like.

Oh, another request ... you want to talk cheesesteaks? The Sixth Sense is available for those comments.
 

MarkTwain

Well-Known Member
Spirited Annual Post Ripping WDW/TDO For Extorting Christmas From Guests:
(For those of you who have been reading these for over a decade or my pals in the PML, you can just skip this post -- but you won't!)

What WDW does for Christmas at the MK truly disgusts me. It has for many years. It doesn't matter, though, as the rubes gladly put their money up to pay for something that used to BE FREE for ALL guests. Time distorts things and the further out we go from those days,the further people forget. If they even knew to begin with ... Much like they forget about Aunt Polly's ... forget about the original Top of the World and its fantastic weekend brunches ... forget about midnight closings at EPCOT (let's not even talk about the park's original purpose/mission) ... forget about higher standards across the board from CMs to cleanliness to show.

So, if I tell folks that the MK used to start MVMCParade and multiple Christmas-themed stage shows (think castle stage, think Tomorrowland exec parking lot, think Diamond Horseshoe) on Thanksgiving weekend and that they included that for all guests, I'm sure I'll get some (how do they put it in that most private of places here?) ... oh yeah, some ****** will try and argue facts or tell me that Disney is a business because no one here knows that.

But, yes, even after Disney started MVMCP (sometime in the 80s as a two-night event), for years they still turned the page and offered the basics to all guests. That stopped in the 90s sometime and every year they have added dates and made it so you have a choice that only an extortionist could love: namely pay an extra admission fee for a party with ever fewer offerings OR wait until around December 20th (some years as late as the 22nd) before the entertainment becomes 'free' for all. All the while you can pay holiday surcharges for meals and pay the highest prices of the year if you are dumb enough to stay at a Disney resort and deal with the absolute worst crowds of the year.

I will point out that this is something that UNI does not do.

I will point out that this is something that Disney in Anaheim, Paris, Hong Kong and Tokyo does not do.

The Grinch may visit IOA at Christmas, but TDO execs play that role at WDW.

And let's not talk about Halloween. While I feel that MNSSHP is overpriced and tired, Disney never had a Halloween season/events before this hard ticket party began. They are offering something extra (again, I may have issue with starting it on Labor Day ... or not clearing the park like they use to ... or the hard sell they do on families by not clearing the park first, but that's not what we're talking about here.) so they didn't take anything away from regular guests to do so.

And before anyone brings up Anaheim, they offer two Halloween overlays to E-Tix that are available to all guests. They never really did Halloween until about a decade ago when they started Halloween parties at DCA. They moved them over to DL about five years ago and while they had introduced a Halloween pyro show the year before it wasn't a tradition. I don't have any issue with it.

Again, what WDW does is a different animal. And it is disgusting.

And please, let's not talk about what Disney does across the resort because we're talking MK here (and really do you want be bashing them for Lights of Winter disappearing or Holiday Illuminations leaving and then having one section tagged on? Or you want me ripping them for killing the fun Jungle Jingle parade at DAK?)

OK, the Christmas extortion thread is out for 2014 ...

Other unpleasant side effects of MVMCP: what happens to guests that pay full price for entry to MK but without paying for the parties.

Those that unknowingly go to Magic Kingdom on the day of the parties (or have no alternative) are forced out by 7, often in a very non-Disney-like manner (being blocked from entering stores on the way out, even to pick up that souvenir that the girl in Adventureland said could be found in the Emporium). No fireworks, no nighttime parade, no nighttime rides on attractions... and no reduction in ticket price.

Those that do the extra research and go in on non-party days are doing so with everyone else, and experience a dramatic upswing in crowds. Crowds on non-party days are beginning to rival days in the busiest times of year, even in the off-season.

I haven't been a fan of the party concept in a long time, so I'm glad someone is finally calling them out for what they are.
 

WDW1974

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
So, one topic that keeps coming up is Disney's load levels at its resorts and whether its numbers are the result of resorts that are truly filled or simply filled to a reduction in capacity.

For example, right now, the Poly, BW and BC (as well as the non-Disney owned Swan) all have substantial numbers of rooms being renovated. At the moderate level, I believe the CBR is the only resort with major room reduction. And, to my knowledge, none of the values has any significant reduction in available rooms.

I just state that because it is very easy to hear the BW is full when only 65% of its rooms are open to be purchased.

I didn't spend enough time at any WDW or UNI resorts in my recent visit to judge their true levels of occupancy versus what it may appear.

OTOH, I did come into some information regarding how much Disney is making from certain rooms. Let's use the Contemporary Resort as an example. They recently had two large groups in for conventions: An Event Apart (500 web design specialists fro around the globe) and the Society of Urologic Nurses and Associates.

The first event had people in as early as 10/23 and out as late as 11/1. The main event was from the 26th thru the 29th, so we'll leave out the other dates. The rate they were charged for a 'Run of the House' (meaning any level/view of room that was available) was $239 a night (overflows were sent to POR for $159 a night). Just wondering when the last time any of you had a Tower Room at the Contemp for $239 a night? (maybe @ParentsOf4 will offer up one of his old posts where he tells you why people book DVC and what they are paying a night)

On the 26th, 164 rooms were blocked out. On the 27th, 183 rooms. On the 28th, 183. On the 29th, it was 125. Again, that doesn't include the POR rooms or the folks who came in early or stayed late. (on the 25th, for example, 60 rooms were blocked)

Think they got a good deal? You should be into urology (fanbois are perking up!) as they paid $199 a night for rooms. (they also had overflow, but at deluxe resorts including the GF and DAK Lodge). Their event ran from 10/30 until 11/2, but many came early or stayed late. For instance, on the 29th, they had 133 rooms blocked.

On the 30th it jumped to 391. On Halloween, it was 400. On the 1st, it was 280.

When you look at those numbers,you start realizing how important Disney's convention business is (recall Disney's issues with mega-casino resorts opening on Miami Beach because they know it would be huge blow to this business). On many nights, a tiny percentage of guests are staying at deluxe resorts and paying rack rate. This is why they plan more DVC conversions of existing Deluxe Resort inventory (check the 8th Wonder thread for more info).

The only way you get a MK view for $199 a night is either by coming with a convention or buying timeshare. Even those 60% off value season rates for CMs are practically non-existent because really ... George Kalogridis and Co don't want CMs using and abusing those great Disney Difference perks that are supposed to make things MAGICal when your $234 a week paycheck gets you living in an old motel room on 192 with two others.

~Rockin' The Spirited Jorts Since The 1980s~
 

WDW1974

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
Talk about up charges. Wdwmagic should give you a special perk. You are one of the reasons people are paying $50 a year to join the PML. ;)

Oh, now just because I might drive considerable traffic here ... and just because I often break news here ... and just because I have a VERY unique perspective on Disney and the folks who run it, doesn't make me special.

Nah, it's my great looks, amazing wit and the ability to get fanbois I have never met to do all sorts of things for me!

(And on a serious note, or more serious, I have never paid a penny to be a part of any online community that I contributed to and I don't believe in it on principle.)
 

Cesar R M

Well-Known Member
Just came back from interstellar...
It makes you think a lot.
Really has a lot of Even Horizon feels + An Space Odyssey.

Wow. Really? I thought BH6 was amazing and absolutely on par with the recent WDA releases and the best of Pixar.

The lines between WDA and Pixar have become blurred to the point where it's almost silly to have them as separate companies anymore. When the same people are making story decisions and in charge of animation quality, it's really just a matter of who is pushing the buttons on the computer at this point.

Oh, and our family LOVES Monsters University. Not everything has to be a tear-jerker to be incredibly entertaining. We watched that movie hundreds of times and it still holds up.

On the other hand, PLANES 2 is a complete and utter disaster. I want my $20 and the hour that it took to watch it back. Horrible. How can a movie about planes fighting fires be SO boring and predictable? It's an embarrassment. Hard to believe the same company that put out Big Hero 6 could put out such garbage. It actually makes Cars 2 sen like a decent movie.
Maybe thats the part where you need to learn.
Because Planes was never made by Pixar. It was done by Disney Toon Studios (usually in charge of doing direct to video sequels).
 

Cesar R M

Well-Known Member
Like most timeshares, DVCs always run at very high occupancy rates, typically over 95%. For the rooms that are bookable by DVC members (vs. DVC rooms that Disney 'owns'), most WDW DVC resorts run at close to 100% year-round. As the largest and perhaps least-desirable WDW DVC resort, Saratoga Springs Resort (SSR) often is the only DVC available on short notice.

For example, a Bay Lake Tower (BLT) Lake View Studio (the easiest Studio to get at BLT) on December 12-14 requires 19 points/night, which works out to $93/night for someone who is a member at SSR but wants to rent at BLT.

The Villas at the Wilderness Lodge (VWL), Boardwalk Villas (BWV), and Beach Club Villas (BCV) are 16 points/night for those nights, so only $79/night for a SSR member.

At those prices, it's obvious why certain DVC resorts fill up. :)
But that is definitively not the price for normal renters in services like David's.
 

WDW1974

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
Other unpleasant side effects of MVMCP: what happens to guests that pay full price for entry to MK but without paying for the parties.

Those that unknowingly go to Magic Kingdom on the day of the parties (or have no alternative) are forced out by 7, often in a very non-Disney-like manner (being blocked from entering stores on the way out, even to pick up that souvenir that the girl in Adventureland said could be found in the Emporium). No fireworks, no nighttime parade, no nighttime rides on attractions... and no reduction in ticket price.

Those that do the extra research and go in on non-party days are doing so with everyone else, and experience a dramatic upswing in crowds. Crowds on non-party days are beginning to rival days in the busiest times of year, even in the off-season.

I haven't been a fan of the party concept in a long time, so I'm glad someone is finally calling them out for what they are.

I agree with everything you said, Mr. Twain.

There is something incredibly tacky about having the 'Ghost Host' come over the park's PA at 6:30 and shill buying tickets to the event and then start playing Party music and showing projections on the MSUSA buildings. I have seen countless family meltdowns and fights because the parents don't have an extra $200-300-400 to buy tix, but all the kids see is everyone else getting to attend a special, way kewl Halloween Party and they aren't allowed in it.

ANd they are savvy (again, thanks to forums like this) about the ways people try and sneak in, if only to see the parade and pyro. I've seen them (I also saw this at UNI at the old Amity bathrooms on this trip and it really bothered me on a HHN) send CMs into restrooms just trying to rush people out and make anyone 'taking care of business' uncomfortable like they were being watched (because they were). And I did see how locked tightly the MSUSA shops were as soon as 7 came, so, yes, if you had wanted to buy something all day but didn't want to carry it around, you were screwed.

If I haven't made myself clear in this thread, then I'll say it again: I'm over O-Town's fall theme park events both at Disney and at UNI. They are a total cluster cluck as the kiddies would say and my tolerance for the kind of aggressive anti-guest enjoyment BS is done. Next fall, if I can't go to Asia (or maybe even if I can) I'll head out to SoCal. I don't want or need any of the stress that these events have become.
 

Cesar R M

Well-Known Member
He never said it was.
he did
On the other hand, PLANES 2 is a complete and utter disaster. I want my $20 and the hour that it took to watch it back. Horrible. How can a movie about planes fighting fires be SO boring and predictable? It's an embarrassment. Hard to believe the same company that put out Big Hero 6 could put out such garbage
Isnt Big Hero 6 Pixar-Disney Studios? (aka not the Disney Toons team)
 

Cesar R M

Well-Known Member
Totally late, but....

Avatar is an incredible journey. Incredible movie? Eh....
Interstellar is an incredible journey and an incredible movie.

EDIT: Scale of Interstellar dwarfs Avatar.
The problem that Interestellar doesn't have much to show other than humans and space.
Avatar as to show entire worlds with animals, fauna and intelligent species other than humans.
 

MarkTwain

Well-Known Member
Maybe thats the part where you need to learn.
Because Planes was never made by Pixar. It was done by Disney Toon Studios (usually in charge of doing direct to video sequels).

True, but it kind of proves his point though. The lines between Disney's and Pixar's output are getting blurred to the point where even Disney fans sometimes don't distinguish them. Planes is an instance where a Disney-branded studio has taken over a Pixar brand, and while many people on a Disney forum know that a cr@ppy movie is the result of DisneyToon Studios, how many in the general public know the difference? Iger has/had a rare thing in Hollywood with Pixar - a movie studio where the studio's brand alone was enough to get people into theaters - but if he tarnishes that with content like Planes (whether Pixar was responsible or not), it could damage the long-term brand.
 

Cesar R M

Well-Known Member
True, but it kind of proves his point though. The lines between Disney's and Pixar's output are getting blurred to the point where even Disney fans sometimes don't distinguish them. Planes is an instance where a Disney-branded studio has taken over a Pixar brand, and while many people on a Disney forum know that a cr@ppy movie is the result of DisneyToon Studios, how many in the general public know the difference? Iger has/had a rare thing in Hollywood with Pixar - a movie studio where the studio's brand alone was enough to get people into theaters - but if he tarnishes that with content like Planes (whether Pixar was responsible or not), it could damage the long-term brand.
You know, I agree with you.
Its almost like they're interchanging plans, products, series.
The revival of the main Disney Animation Studios (Wreck it Ralph and now big Hero 6) says a lot of the revival and influence.
 

WDW1974

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
Popping in briefly here -- still catching up on things on the homefront after my journeys through Asia. I'll post more a little later, but to set up the context:

Nice to see you back in MAGIC Land. :)

I was in Orlando for a couple of days in the early fall, and had the chance to experience the attractions that were new to me since my visit a year ago -- chiefly 7DMT and Gringotts. I may post more about my O-Town sojourn later (though I'll likely focus on the Asian parks), but Mr. '74 has very concisely encapsulated my own opinions.

I then spent a couple of weeks traveling through Asia, hitting up the major Southeast Asia parks and their Halloween festivities -- Universal Studios Singapore and its Halloween Horror Nights, Hong Kong Disneyland, and Ocean Park. So I had a pretty good chance to compare Universal's domestic vs. foreign offerings, as well as the WDW parks vs. HKDL (which I'd visited once a number of years ago, when the park was much sparser on attractions), with very fresh memories.

In a nutshell: Mystic Manor is AMAZING. My expectations were high, but MM completely blew me away. (I think the message I sent '74 right after I experienced it said something like, "When the ride ended, I had to suppress the urge to clap like a trained seal.") Having experienced every major Disney and Universal attraction thus far (with the exception of Ratatouille), I can safely say that MM is not only Disney's best attraction, but the best theme park attraction anywhere. I don't think it's even close. The POV videos give you some idea of the attraction, but there is an immersiveness to the special effects, coupled with the movement of the trackless vehicles, that the videos just can't provide.


Yes, you did say that. But, to be fair, I've seen you act that way everytime we dine out and your food arrives at the table!:D

When I hear people like yourself and @WDWFigment say such things, at the same time people who worked on O-Town's best new offerings at DA are saying it, it makes me feel good because I really fell in love with HKDL the first sweltering day I spent there back in 2008. And it just keeps getting better all the time.

But please, fanbois, MM is NOT coming to WDW. Not now. Not ever. It may be a unique creation, but it IS HKDL's Haunted Mansion and it just isn't coming here as we already have one.

On the whole, HKDL and its resort hotels are being operated and maintained on a level comparable to TDR. If you were to take Mystic Point and drop it in Tokyo DisneySea, there would not be any appreciable difference in the level of theming and details. As another example, it's a small world (which, as an aside, is the best version of the Happiest Cruise That Ever Sailed) looked like it opened yesterday -- without a single effect or doll or lightbulb inside or outside of the attraction inoperational or compromised in any way.

The HKDL hotel might look like a "Reader's Digest condensed version" of the GF, but it's really like a boutique version -- the room rates are comparable to those of the WL or AKL, but the level of service and upkeep far exceeds that of any WDW resort. The buses that run between the hotels and the park supposedly run every 10 minutes, but I never waited more than 3 or 4 minutes for a bus, even at the end of the day when the park closed -- they simply operated more buses, so that a new one pulled up as soon as one was full.

I'm only a Faux Top One Percenter, unlike yourself and Mrs. Bricker's husband, I have yet to stay in such pricey digs. I guess I'm just used to getting 4-star hotels in HK for $75-130 a night. But I have spent a lot of time at both and they are immaculately maintained (would anyone ever say that about ANY WDW resort?) have great and reasonable dining and amazing views (when it is clear) of the HK skyline across the South China Sea. And I also never had a wait for a bus there ... ever.

And CMs everywhere were efficient, knowledgeable, and friendly -- I really felt the "Disney difference" between HKDL CMs and those at USS or OP (or, for that matter, WDW or UF).

Anyway, more to come a little later... but HKDL exceeded my expectations in every possible way, and left me optimistic for the future of both HKDL and Disney parks generally -- clearly Imagineering still has some tricks up its sleeve that it can (if it chooses to) deploy stateside...

Looking forward to hearing more. Welcome back!
 

WDW1974

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
True, but it kind of proves his point though. The lines between Disney's and Pixar's output are getting blurred to the point where even Disney fans sometimes don't distinguish them. Planes is an instance where a Disney-branded studio has taken over a Pixar brand, and while many people on a Disney forum know that a cr@ppy movie is the result of DisneyToon Studios, how many in the general public know the difference? Iger has/had a rare thing in Hollywood with Pixar - a movie studio where the studio's brand alone was enough to get people into theaters - but if he tarnishes that with content like Planes (whether Pixar was responsible or not), it could damage the long-term brand.

Coming in the middle of a discussion, but my time is very limited right now, but I don't see Planes harming any BRAND -- Disney's or Pixar's.

The first film was actually decent. I saw it last fall on my Disney MAGIC voyage and was pleasantly surprised. haven't seen the second one as it isn't on my radar really. If I see it sometime, fine. If not, then that's cool too.

Animation is clearly peaking again at Disney, which should be a great thing for the parks (although all that Frozen stuff coming now should have been there last year, but they just don't trust anything they do now unless it's from Marvel).

Pixar isn't exactly in the toilet, either. No, their last three films haven't been great and coming off TS3 in 2010 I think it would have been very tough to top that. But the last three films still made a ton of money and sold a ton of merchandise. And none of the films (yes, including Cars 2) were awful. I do think they were more aimed at kids, at least Cars 2 and Brave. I really enjoyed Monsters U a lot. So, I don't see any luster off the Pixar BRAND at all.

Of course, my opinions are simply one Spirit's, but there isn't a Disney animated film released in the 1990s (that includes everything up to Tarzan in 99) that I didn't feel was better than Frozen.
 

WDW1974

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
You know, I agree with you.
Its almost like they're interchanging plans, products, series.
The revival of the main Disney Animation Studios (Wreck it Ralph and now big Hero 6) says a lot of the revival and influence.

That's what Disney does, though.

That's why JK Rowling ultimately wanted no part of Disney. Can't you see the lines of Vinylmation? How about the Potter characters mashed up as Cars? Or in a Marvel toon for Disney's XD channel?

I was in the Home Depot yesterday and saw Christmas decorations everywhere. There was a huge inflatable Darth Vader holding a candy cane. That's tacky and dumb and oh so Disney. George Lucas doesn't care.

Look at Disney Infinity (what every 33-year-old virgin Lifestyler is playing) where you have characters like Donald and Stitch and the Incredibles and MOnsters and the Lone Ranger and Captain Jack and now the Marvel characters all existing in one MAGICal Disney BRANDED UNIverse.

You either think that's great or you think like I do.
 

WDW1974

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
The really scary thing is that all of Disney's current strategies, whether we like them or not, seem to be working wonderfully, at least in terms of maximizing profits and maintaining their workforce. Who are we to say they're charting the wrong course?

We are the consumers, the workers and the fans.
Some of us are shareholders as well.

We have every right to say they are charting the wrong course.
 

WDW1974

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
Congratulations on summarizing what Short Term thinking is and illustrating why many Western societies think American enterprise has no soul.

Just because something works today, does not mean it will continue working in the future. Just because something looks like its working, doesn't mean its not hurting something else... something else that can be far more difficult to fix.

Just because I can drive my workers into the ground because they have no where else to go doesn't mean I should. Do you have any comprehension at all about the relationship between work quality and worker satisfaction?

When your business is customer service and exceeding expectations... you won't get there with employees who are treated like **** and only work there out of lack of something better.

Before the 2008 meltdown, Disney (DL in particular) was having an aweful time in employee quality and retention... because of the 'course' you are advocating as not so bad. The issue only improved when employees were happy to have any job they could. So now they have a more stable workforce... of inferior employees.

Yeah, who are we to say any of the above is wrong?
cdl6.jpg

I hate to inflate your huge ego, but that post may be one of the best you have dropped here. And considering you and I don't always see eye to eye on business matters, that says quite a lot!
 

WDW1974

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
Companies and their employees are not evaluated solely on 'profits' in most parts of the world. Its that very focus and justification that shows just how broken society has gotten. There is a reason the US never ends up on top of 'best countries to live in' rankings.. and failing to address short term vision is a large part of it.

Nope. That's very much an American way of thinking.

So short sighted, so narrowminded.

This country is so effed right now and we didn't get here overnight (and it wasn't just the last Prez and the current one who caused it either ... not even close!)

No one thinks of what will be left to our children and grandchildren and theirs.

What's important is what the market does today. It's absurd and obscene and, no with apologies to any Texans here, it does not make us No. 1 at anything other than pomposity.
 
Last edited:

ThemeParkJunkee

Well-Known Member
Trying to catch up after my internet free weekend (no access at the lake house). Holy **** Batman. Meanwhile, here in the center of "Winter Storm Astro"...I am looking at over a foot of snow on the way. Luckily, we finally got the leaf thing done at the lake house, the driveway marked with orange stakes and we are ready.

One pertinent comment...I agree with Mr. Spirit...I just spent 9 days with the mouse on site and I am a stockholder (but rely on others for the analyses). I have every right to my opinion. I'll be back with mine when I catch up.
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom