I hate that people place the blame of current Disney disappointments on the engineers.
They are doing what is asked of them and budgeted for. If management doesn’t want something it doesn’t matter what level of talent is underneath them.
But it’s always easier to blame the workers I guess.
I definitely don’t blame the Imagineers in terms of their dedication or talent. As an outsider looking in, I do sometimes wonder if there’s been a loss of institutional knowledge over time. Or maybe not - it may be all about expectations and budgets. I don’t know and I’m not invested in one answer over the other, but I am somewhat curious about it.
In terms of positives - I think recent Disney excels in the area of technology, and should be applauded for that. I get all weepy about what humankind has accomplished when I watch Disney documentaries, it’s really amazing. I think they’re branching out in new directions and trying new things, which is great. I think their use of lighting at night is a newish phenomenon and looks great. And I think they make things that are quite lovely, if sometimes a little nondescript (Usually… CommuniCore Hall is more than “a little” nondescript. But in general.)
In terms of criticisms - I sometimes just wonder if the days of truly amazing design intricacy are behind us for the foreseeable future. I have a hard time imagining something like New Orleans Square, World Showcase, or Animal Kingdom being built today. Or for rides - I have a hard time seeing something like Pirates, Mansion, or Splash being built today.
Not that intricacy of design is the be-all end-all. I’ll be honest, I’m pretty basic, if you make a new lounge and serve me a cocktail with one of those weird fog bubbles on top, I’ll be pretty happy. Add a seasonal sorcerer’s hat dessert and I’m thrilled, lol. But things like all the rock work over building architecture - yeah, I am kinda curious where that comes from. Maybe the knowledge of how to build that kind of thing is too esoteric these days, or maybe it’s budget and other concerns, like guests damaging the buildings.