MK Cars-Themed Attractions at Magic Kingdom

[eddie104]

I know they are also attempting to drive their agenda before anything else.

This is where we will agree to disagree. I don’t want get into a heated political discussion.

I will just say diversity is good and having a variety of opinions is a must in any successful company.

If Disneyland thought it made business sense to keep the island and boats - why doesn’t WDW?

ROA in DL is crucial as they use it for Fantasmic.

TSI seems to be more popular on the West Coast for some reason.

 

[TrainsOfDisney]

ROA in DL is crucial as they use it for Fantasmic.

Nothing was keeping them from building a WDW type Fantasmic stage - would allow for more expansion and make operations much simpler since cast and equipment wouldn’t have to cross over by raft.

TSI seems to be more popular on the West Coast for some reason.

Both seem to be attended about the same in my anecdotal experiences.

 

[rd805]

Typing this from Tom Sawyer island - can you give an example or properly utilized attractions? Is there a specific number of daily visitors?

If Disneyland thought it made business sense to keep the island and boats - why doesn’t WDW?

Would the sheer # of visitors be a good enough reason? MK always seems pretty slammed -- it's been a bit since I've went to DL, but I would say it's a much easier experience to navigate with shorter wait times.

 

[Chi84]

They could have turned TSI into another Camp Minnie-Mickey with a Pocahontas show and character meets.

What happened to Camp Minnie-Mickey?

 

[TrainsOfDisney]

What happened to Camp Minnie-Mickey?

It became avatar land. It was designed as a placeholder and they built a brand new theatre for the only remaining attraction in the land. (Pocahontas had already closed - it wasn’t really a Disney worthy show).

 

[𝐌𝖆𝖓 𝖎𝖓 𝐖𝖊𝖇]

I feel like Disney and others insist on putting numbers and metrics on everything. Sometimes, it is just about the atmosphere that something brings to an area to make a better experience. It can be integral of the land without even knowing it..or forgetting that you once knew this to be the case. When it comes to Frontierland, that is what RoA and TSI are to me.

Would Piston Peak not provide much of the same? Per the concept art it looks as though it could.

 

[flynnibus]

I don’t want to speak for others, but I feel as though the majority of those who are upset with this decision are more disappointed with the lack of creativity and heart behind it.

Then why is the loudest noise about ROA going away.. and why was all the noise before anything really of substance is known about the actual attractions?

 

[Chi84]

Would Piston Peak not provide much of the same? Per the concept art it looks as though it could.

If it could be designed to continue the concept and at the same time have a more popular attraction, that would be a good thing.

 

[flynnibus]

o be fair I think the more common sentiment is to always give imagineers a pass and blame everything on Iger and the suits

And the common thread? Both sides acting like they know the actual workings without a lick of actual direct knowledge. Which why all of it is basically useless fanrage.

 

[𝐌𝖆𝖓 𝖎𝖓 𝐖𝖊𝖇]

And the common thread? Both sides acting like they know the actual workings without a lick of actual direct knowledge. Which why all of it is basically useless fanrage.

Welcome to the internets. This is WDWMagic a forum where we talk about such things. Hi, my name is Alec Azam and I'm an addict. What brings you here today?

Coffee and donuts at the back of the gymnasium.

 

[phillip9698]

Partially…. This is completely counter to the thinking of the design of the WDW resort. The resort was planned to have large portions “underutilized” - Disneyland is the opposite with attractions literally on top of each other.

That doesn’t mean that every single attraction has to continue operating - although understanding nostalgia is important for the Disney theme park business.

But the decisions to cut rivers of America and muppets are particularly upsetting.

Disneyland has attractions on top of each other because they can be. You can’t do that in Florida when you are building on swamp land.

The water table matters!

 

[mickEblu]

And the common thread? Both sides acting like they know the actual workings without a lick of actual direct knowledge. Which why all of it is basically useless fanrage.

Well then let’s just all shut up and shut down all the threads except for Trip reports. Lol.

 

[TheMaxRebo]

Would Piston Peak not provide much of the same? Per the concept art it looks as though it could.

I hope so - and looks like it could with walking paths by the geysers, etc. Hopefully plenty of places to sit throughout too

There is potential here, but will come down to final execution

 

[Chi84]

Well then let’s just all shut up and shut down all the threads except for Trip reports. Lol.

There’s a difference between true discussion and simply stating one’s unfounded opinions as fact.

People have a right to call that out.

 

[FettFan]

I don’t want to speak for others, but I feel as though the majority of those who are upset with this decision are more disappointed with the lack of creativity and heart behind it.

No. It seems to me like the general consensus is that at least the lower island of TSI could/should have been preserved while RoA would be truncated with the Belle still running a loop past the Mansion and Big Thunder.

 

[TrainsOfDisney]

No. It seems to me like the general consensus is that at least the lower island of TSI could/should have been preserved while RoA would be truncated with the Belle still running a loop past the Mansion and Big Thunder.

Exactly. I’d be fine with the smaller part of the island becoming a cars / National park area with TSI style trails.

Losing the riverboat is the big issue.

 

[Disney Analyst]

Disneyland has attractions on top of each other because they can be. You can’t do that in Florida when you are building on swamp land.

The water table matters!

They can build Everest but can’t build something like Alice in Wonderland that goes partially over Mr. Toad?

 

[FettFan]

What happened to Camp Minnie-Mickey?

 

[TrainsOfDisney]

Disneyland has attractions on top of each other because they can be. You can’t do that in Florida when you are building on swamp land.

The water table matters!

MK is literally built on top of the utilodors.

 

[Disney Analyst]

MK is literally built on top of the utilodors.

WDW is made up of insane super structures. They could very easily engineer a better density ratio like at Disneyland.

And even Disneyland only has a few specific attractions that are built on top of one another.