Assuming it's also a suite on the cruise ship then I am going with the cruise. Call me crazy but the stay in the Castle would be nice but it's not an "OMG" type of thing for me.
Since I know Dear Hubby is planning a cruise for our 5 year anniversary I voted for the Castle Suite. Even if the cruise was not in my future I would still have voted the Castle because like so many have said you just can't get in there unless your some celeb or luck out enough to be picked to spend a night, which I don't think they are doing any more. It's like Club 33. Not everyone can get in
I can book a cruise anytime but a night in the Cinderella Castle suite is something I can only dream of! So a suite for me. I mean, I would think a good portion of us can't afford the very expensive hotels like Ritz Carlton and would do anything to experience luxury. With Cinderella Castle, that's luxury, Disney style. Only it's something that money can't buy....literally!
Didn't even have to think about answering that one for one second. Definitely the 1 night stay in the castle. It's a once in a lifetime opportunity, I wouln't miss out on that one if given the chance.
Not something that many people get to experience. Plus I'm not a fan of cruises. I'd rather just fly and spend more time exploring the tropical island.
I'm sure the cruise would be nice and you'd certainly get 4 days out of it vs. the 1 in the castle BUT cruising is a common experience you could easily buy. While Disney Cruises weren't available when I was a kid, I think back to the good old Love Boat days. I realize the Love Boat is not a Disney cruise, but it still seemed like a really fun idea as a kid. Fun...but not awesome - brag to all of your friends - amazing - like a getting to spend a night in the castle always seemed.
I've always wanted to stay in the Castle suite so I'm voting for that. The cruise you can book at any time. It would be neat if they did have the Castle suite available for bookings!!
The cruises are great, but note: "cruise(s)"; the Castle would be, for all intents and purposes, a once in a lifetime opportunity. (and even that, the night stay, is only conjecture for the aforementioned poll)