Oh, yeah, I always tip doormen or supes. I think the people who are trying to normalize tipping your landlord are people who aren't contracting with management companies. They are doing it all themselves and I think they have realized the income is not as "passive" as they were led to believe.
You unlocked some bad memories here, not bad, but more like, WTH?
When we first moved back to the States, we rented a one bedroom unit in a condo building in Chicago. The man who owned it was French and he moved back to France, but he kept it as an investment. He was very chill and very attentive to any issue that came up. Anyway, the Holidays came around and the company who was maintaining the building was collecting money for tips for the 2 doormen who worked downstairs. This was in 2000, we tipped $100 to be split. After Christmas, a piece of paper was taped in the elevators, It was a thank you from the management company, but they put everyone's name, unit and the amount they tipped.
OMG, we totally undertipped. It went from $200-$350. This floored me and I was really embarrassed. This was really tacky, IMO.
The next apartment we moved into was a 2 flat that was built in about 1910-20. The landlord lived a block away and I think this was his first time being a landlord. It was super cute and in a fun neighborhood with other young families. One of the reasons we jumped on it was bc it had central AC, which is uncommon in older buildings. One day, it was early April and it was 85 outside. My husband turned on the AC, after a few minutes, we realize the apartment is not getting cooler. My husband phoned the landlord and he told him he hadn't installed it yet.
But wait, there's more! This guy decided he wanted to renovate the basement that was directly under us and make it into another apartment. For starters, the guy he hired to do this was an alcoholic. The back door to our unit opened to an unfinished unit that was just studs and joists. My husband heard bottles clanking coming from this unfinished unit and thought it was kids or something. It was the contractor "living" there. His GF kicked him out. So he started living in that unfinished unit. Then, he started renovating the basement. He rented a small earth mover. This generated CO2 which set off the detector. I would have to open my windows in January to get it out. I could only do this for so long before they were activated again. Then I would have to dress my son, who was a toddler at the time, put him in his stroller and walk around my neighborhood. It's always fun to be outside in Chicago in January.
My landlord knew this was happening, because I was going to his house to tell him. It happened so much, my husband started taking money off the rent checks and the landlord didn't say a peep. I am not even sure he got a permit to do this. I am sure he didn't, because it is illegal to make the basement into an apartment of a 2 flat in Chicago.
We left when the lease was up because I was spending so much time at my grandmother's house because of the CO2. I don't think he rented that unit out until the basement was complete. A month after we left, my brother called me and told me to turn the news on. This apartment building was being covered live, because it collapsed.