This is a tough one as I am a DVC member.I won at BW but never stayed and love the GF. But I think the Poly is the best resort, stayed there often as a child
Although I have only visited and not stayed at all the resorts, nothing will ever be able to replace the Polynesian as my favorite. So many memories of family trips to WDW growing up and we stayed there every time except once.
Animal Kindom is my favorite, with Wilderness Lodge at a close second, and YC/BC/Boardwalk at third. But I only like staying at AKL when I have a Savannah view. It is a must!
I'm gonna have to go with the Boardwalk. There's just so much to do right there at the hotel. It's almost like a little Pleasure Island. I love the proximity to Epcot and MGM and the Boardwalk Bakery has some of the best sweets in the world.
I also love AKL, but havent stayed there. The animals, Boma, and Jiko are a great combination in my book.
Noticed your avatar seems like we have a star wars fan here! that makes two of us!! Actually I am a fanatic I actually made a SW site until the whole thing became destroyed needless to say i was devestated