We did this with my oldest nephew a few years ago. He thought it was great and was really excited about the golf ball. The next time we went on, we didn't have another golf ball so we all tried to catch it but missed. He justified it by saying that you can only catch it in the top row.
Fast forward to last January and we wanted to do it again. This time we had three golf balls and three kids to give them to. One was my oldest nephew who thought it was great, another family friend was also entertained, but he had been on the attraction before so this didn't really register as a "trick" to him. The last was a third family friendly who hadn't been on the ride before. She didn't get it, was spooked, and pushed the ball away. It fell down into the no man's area between the screen and the railing. The adults spent the remainder of the ride laughing hysterically, and then immediately getting all of the kids out of the theater as soon as possible.