Dole Whip, Trader Sam's Tiki Terrace, Dinner at Kona inside the Polynesian, riding Everest over and over (my daughter did it 21 times in one day a few years ago).
Club Cool has been a part of each of our trips too. What is it about Beverly? It's that weird thing where someone tells you something tastes terrible, and then you try it anyway!
I only discovered Club Cool on my last trip and whilst there I decided to try a Beverly. I figured it couldn't be as bad as everyone on here made it out to be.
Eating at 'Ohana was our tradition for every trip, but on our last trip we decided we would not be doing that anymore. It just didn't seem worth it. But, we always try new places too, so I guess that counts.