WDWmagic Forums: WDW Ride Consensus Rankings

[Ayla]

Oh I thought there was an end goal here. I guess I’m wasting my time then.

Yeah, I gave up after about 75.

 

[Purduevian]

Yeah, I gave up after about 75.

I did warn you haha.

Vote on what ride you think is better. Voting never ends. Click the "results" tab to see where each ride currently ranks.

VOTE HERE

 

[Agent H]

Yeah, I gave up after about 75.

75 votes or 75 rounds?

 

[Ayla]

I did warn you haha.

That meant to me there was no deadline for voting, not that it would be a never-ending process.

 

[Ayla]

75 votes or 75 rounds?

Seventy five votes, which I think got me to round 3?

 

[ᗩLᘿᑕ ֊ᗩζᗩᗰ]

These mostly line up with my own. Good to see. Means I'm not crazy. Though,I do question why Test Track is ranked so high. And while not super surprising I am shocked to see Barnstormer so low. Wonder if they should revisit that, plus it somehow.

 

[UNCgolf]

I've always said Navi River Journey is the best C ticket at the parks despite the disdain for it here... and the votes back me up! It even beat out a few D tickets.

 

[ᗩLᘿᑕ ֊ᗩζᗩᗰ]

I've always said Navi River Journey is the best C ticket at the parks despite the disdain for it here... and the votes back me up! It even beat out a few D tickets.

Well I mean, out of 50+ it's nearly center of the pack at #25. Which, I guess is par for a C-ticket, though coming in at 52% forum approval doesn't look all that great. I wonder if we could assign E-A tickets based on the rankings here?

 

[UNCgolf]

Well I mean, out of 50+ it's nearly center of the pack at #25. Which, I guess is par for a C-ticket, though coming in at 52% forum approval doesn't look all that great. I wonder if we could assign E-A tickets based on the rankings here?

That's basically what it should get as a C ticket -- it shouldn't be beating any E or D tickets (although it did).

It's also not 52% approval; it's not is this ride good yes/no question. It's entirely possible that NRJ could only get 40% if it was that yes/no question but that's not what this measured.

To be fair, though, this really isn't enough data to draw any conclusions even about people on this forum, much less the general public.

 

[ᗩLᘿᑕ ֊ᗩζᗩᗰ]

That's basically what it should get as a C ticket -- it shouldn't be beating any E or D tickets (although it did).

It's also not 52% approval; it's not is this ride good yes/no question. It's entirely possible that NRJ could only get 40% if it was that yes/no question but that's not what this measured.

To be fair, though, this really isn't enough data to draw any conclusions even about people on this forum, much less the general public.

Weighted average. Grade on a curve. No child left behind. NRJ get's 3 gold stars and a participation trophy. Potential squandered but still a solid C ticket.

 

[UNCgolf]

Weighted average. Grade on a curve. No child left behind. NRJ get's 3 gold stars and a participation trophy. Potential squandered but still a solid C ticket.

Nah, definitely no squandered potential. I'm not sure what they could even do to improve it while remaining a C ticket. Immersive, great physical sets, possibly the best use of screens/projections on any Disney attraction. It's one of the better rides they've built this century at WDW; imagine how much better something like Tiana would be if they'd learned from what NRJ does so well.

I honestly don't think I've ever seen a complaint about it that isn't describing turning into a D or E ticket (other than the wait time, which is definitely too long). I'd love a D or E ticket version, but it wasn't built to be that.

 

[Purduevian]

Weighted average. Grade on a curve. No child left behind. NRJ get's 3 gold stars and a participation trophy. Potential squandered but still a solid C ticket.

This polling in no way determines the ticket level of a ride or even if it is a good ride or not. Simply, does the average user rate Ride A above Ride B.