-
Welcome to the WDWMAGIC.COM Forums!
Please take a look around, and feel free to sign up and join the community.
WDWmagic Forums: WDW Ride Consensus Rankings
- Thread starter Purduevian
- Start date
1000 votes in ( I plan to leave this open for at least a week)
Top 10:
41. Kali River Rapids
42. The Barnstormer
43. Dumbo the Flying Elephant
44. The Magic Carpets of Aladdin
45. Prince Charming Regal Carrousel
46. The Seas with Nemo & Friends
47. Mad Tea Party
48. Tomorrowland Speedway
49. Astro Orbiter
50. Main Street Vehicles
51. Liberty Square Riverboat
Top 10:
- Avatar Flight of Passage
- Kilimanjaro Safaris
- The Twilight Zone Tower of Terror
- Big Thunder Mountain Railroad
- Expedition Everest - Legend of the Forbidden Mountain
- Star Wars: Rise of the Resistance
- Guardians of the Galaxy: Cosmic Rewind
- Soarin' Around the World
- Tiana's Bayou Adventure - New!
- Toy Story Mania!
41. Kali River Rapids
42. The Barnstormer
43. Dumbo the Flying Elephant
44. The Magic Carpets of Aladdin
45. Prince Charming Regal Carrousel
46. The Seas with Nemo & Friends
47. Mad Tea Party
48. Tomorrowland Speedway
49. Astro Orbiter
50. Main Street Vehicles
51. Liberty Square Riverboat
DisneyFanatic12
Well-Known Member
Good to see BTMRR up there
TBA in top ten?
Baloo124
Premium Member
TBA and TSM are top 10 but HM and POTC aren't?
This election is officially rigged. I'm storming the Capitol.
*Disclaimer. For legal reasons or anyone who takes this too seriously, I am NOT actually storming the Capitol. But I will in fact wave my finger and chant "Shame on You!" at anyone who is responsible for both HM and POTC not being in the top 10 thus far, and will remain highly ashamed of you all until this changes.
DisneyFanatic12
Well-Known Member
Pirates and Haunted Mansion are number 11 and 13 respectively. Pirates is almost in top ten category while HM’s ranking is, well, fitting for the ride at 13th.
~24 hours in with over 5.2k votes!
Top Ten:
41: The Seas with Nemo & Friends
42: Liberty Square Riverboat
43: Main Street Vehicles
44: Alien Swirling Saucers
45: Dumbo the Flying Elephant
46: Astro Orbiter
47: Prince Charming Regal Carrousel
48: The Barnstormer
49: Mad Tea Party
50: The Magic Carpets of Aladdin
51: Tomorrowland Speedway
Top Ten:
- The Twilight Zone Tower of Terror
- Expedition Everest- Legend of the Forbidden Mountain
- Big Thunder Mountain Railroad
- Avatar Flight of Passage
- Kilimnjaro Safaris
- Guardians of the Galaxy: Cosmic Rewind
- Star Wars: Rise of the Resistance
- Space Mountain
- Soarin' Around the World
- Haunted Mansion
41: The Seas with Nemo & Friends
42: Liberty Square Riverboat
43: Main Street Vehicles
44: Alien Swirling Saucers
45: Dumbo the Flying Elephant
46: Astro Orbiter
47: Prince Charming Regal Carrousel
48: The Barnstormer
49: Mad Tea Party
50: The Magic Carpets of Aladdin
51: Tomorrowland Speedway
Things are getting worse for those 2 as votes roll in... HM currently sitting at 13... Pirates as dropped to 16th...
Not sure if there are trolls in the polls or if I actually view those 2 much higher than general public.
What's more concerning... There's only 51 rides in the entirety of WDW?
Well I did exclude Disney springs rides (Balloon, carousel, train, and car boat things). I also didn't include things where I felt the main purpose was transportation (Wildlife express train, monorail, various boats, and the rafts to tom sawyers Island).
A couple of rides were right on the edge for me, but I decided to include them because I don't think the "reason" people ride them is to get from A-B (main street vehicles and the MK railroad). More of an enjoy the ride, not the destination type things
The final one that I thought about was COP... it's really more of a show, but I couldn't think of any reason it wasn't a ride. I'm glad Honey I shrunk the audience isn't around anymore... because technically those seats did move a few inches up during the show, then dropped a few inches right at the end.
In theory the ride count will go up +2 for tropical Americas, +1 for cars land (loosing the boat), +2 for Villains, +1 for monsters Inc for a total of 57
Baloo124
Premium Member
I just checked. ToT is currently #1 and HM is back in the top 10.
There's reason to have faith in humanity once more.
POTC is still lagging behind the top 10, but I get many people feel is lacks compared to the what could have been from it's Disneyland coutnerpart.
DisneyFanatic12
Well-Known Member
Looks like both HM and PotC have entered the top 10 now, but it probably won’t last.
~48 hours in with 13,688 Votes:
41. Mission: SPACE
42. Liberty Square Riverboat
43: Astro Orbiter
44: Dumbo the Flying Elephant
45: Alien Swirling Saucers
46: Mad Tea Party
47: Main Street Vehicles
48: Prince Charming Regal Carrousel
49: The Barnstormer
50. The Magic Carpets of Aladdin
51: Tomorrowland Speedway
- The Twilight Zone Tower of Terror
- Avatar Flight of Passage
- Expedition Everest - Legend of the Forbidden Mountain
- Big Thunder Mountain Railroad
- Guardians of the Galaxy: Cosmic Rewind
- Kilimanjaro Safaris
- Star Wars: Rise of the Resistance
- Space Mountain
- Haunted Mansion
- Pirates of the Caribbean
41. Mission: SPACE
42. Liberty Square Riverboat
43: Astro Orbiter
44: Dumbo the Flying Elephant
45: Alien Swirling Saucers
46: Mad Tea Party
47: Main Street Vehicles
48: Prince Charming Regal Carrousel
49: The Barnstormer
50. The Magic Carpets of Aladdin
51: Tomorrowland Speedway
ParadoxPortals
Active Member
I think that's the truth of the matter with the Riverboat. Today it's climbed to 42/51, a great improvement but still terrible. People don't really enjoy the ride much, it serves as excellent ambiance and is a cool idea, but I think the issue with it going - apart from the destruction of Frontierland's kinesis and vibe - is more to do with its awful replacement than the loss of the boat itself. Don't get me wrong, I deeply value the boat's existence, but it's always been a low popularity ride, that's just the truth. We didn't even ride it on our visit last year knowing it was going away.
Agent H
Well-Known Member
I’m the opposite. I don’t like the cars idea but removing the rivers of America seems like an idea that should have never even been considered.
ParadoxPortals
Active Member
I feel like big water features in hot Floridian theme parks are super important, it's defo a shame to lose the river. I'm fine to lose Tom Sawyer's Island, but the river itself is gonna suck. Would've been cool if the replacement helped to connect the land up more so it's less of a giant C-shape by including a more direct cut-through to Big Thunder / Tiana's from Liberty Square.
My dream replacement would be a new Western River Expedition that was a Navi River Journey slow vibe ride, no drops or anything, partly indoors and outside. Would've sated the fan's need for a water ride that adds kineses as well as being an original non-IP attraction amongst the current slate of plans. That would never happen but would've been awesome.
I could compromise for a Woody's Roundup (Toy Story) attraction in Frontierland of some kind, but we have too much Toy Story in the parks ATM IMO. Maybe a Lone Ranger ride (lmao). Really no modern IP could work thematically in Frontierland, it would have to be non-IP.
Chef Mickey
Well-Known Member
BREAKING: A Federal Judge has blocked the democratically voted top 10 list and has ordered the bottom 10 list to be the ACTUAL top 10 list.
Baloo124
Premium Member
BREAKING: Live coverage of Tomorrowland Speedway victory lap and parade currently being aired on all major news outlets.
The Judge who allowed this shocking twist of events to occur wouldn't answer reporters as to why he stripped ToT and other top contenders of their chances of victory, but did take a moment to say that he really really really hates the Los Angeles Dodgers.