WDW Counter-Service/Restaurant Madness: Ultimate Championship

What is your favorite dining location?


  • Total voters
    43

Splashman

Member
Original Poster
Throughout the WDW Counter-Service Madness tournament, especially in the later rounds, there was some questions on how the members of WDWMagic vote for their favorite places to eat. The debate was based on which qualities people take into consideration when choosing where to eat. Do people choose atmosphere and nostalgia over quality of food, variety in selections of food over location, and so on. There are a lot of factors which can determine where people eat in WDW and these will obviously influence their choices of favorite. I thought it would be fun to see how people vote when placing two places on opposite ends of the food spectrum against each other. To do this, I am going to place the winner of the WDW Restaurant Fall Madness tournament against the winner of the WDW Counter-Service Madness tournament in order to determine the members of WDWMagic's favorite place to eat in all of WDW. On paper these places are heavily mismatched, but I want to see which takes a higher preference: atmosphere and nostalgia, quality of food, selection, overall experience, etc. It will be interesting to see how this plays out.

For the ultimate championship, the dining location to receive the most votes after 48 hours has passed from the time of the start of the match will be the winner. You are voting for which place you like better taking into consideration overall quality, atmosphere, experience, etc. So, you are voting for one place and please feel free to comment or discuss why you voted that way as these threads are in the discussion forum. You may place your vote in the poll and/or write it out though I would prefer everyone vote by means of the poll. Obviously, if you have not been to all the places, then only vote for the place you have experienced if you like.

The Ultimate Championship:

WDW Restaurant Fall Madness Champion vs. WDW Counter-Service Madness Champion

California Grill (Contemporary) vs. Pecos Bill Tall Tale Inn and Cafe (Magic Kingdom)

This match will end at 12:30pm on Friday 12/31/2010.

Have fun!
 

WDWmazprty

Well-Known Member
Awesome Splashman!

Gotta go with California Grill out of these two. It has everything; atmosphere, quality of food, location. Pecos does have that nostalgia factor, but its not enough to overtake Cali Grill IMHO. :wave:
 

Rinx

Well-Known Member
Pecos due to the convenience factor. Cali is too much of a big what-to-do. It's nice to do once every couple of years or so.
 

captainkidd

Well-Known Member
I can't believe these 2 are pitted against one another. A burger and fries joint (that serves the same burgers and fries as every other burger place in WDW) versus a world class dining experience.:confused:
 

Splashman

Member
Original Poster
I can't believe these 2 are pitted against one another. A burger and fries joint (that serves the same burgers and fries as every other burger place in WDW) versus a world class dining experience.:confused:

If you read the original posting above you would understand why they are against each other.
 

Splashman

Member
Original Poster
So far Pecos Bill leads California Grill with about a half of day remaining to vote. In a few hours we will see which WDW dining location truly reigns supreme.
 

Splashman

Member
Original Poster
The Ultimate Championship match is now over and the final score is:

Pecos Bill Tall Tale Inn and Cafe edges out California Grill 22-18.

Congratulations to Pecos Bill in becoming the ultimate champion and WDWMagic's favorite dining location in all of WDW.
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom