At least for me, one of the best parts of the older version from 1994 was the score itself. Everything from the entrance to the exit and return to earth just fit together so well. I can't imagine how hard it is to create a soundtrack to an attraction, especially because things have to mix well for people to really enjoy it.
I found that the new soundtrack is really great on the outside entrance and loading areas. Then it just simply becomes nonsense the rest of the ride. I think the part that struck me as a step backwards was the removal of the great track for the monks, to be replaced with a chorus of simply "amen amen amen amen amen." Yuck, I don't think monks really just sit there and say amen over and over again.
One other thing, the music was short. Getting stopped for a few minutes during the computer scene really let me notice how short the loops really are now. I remember riding SSE, and having a slightly different mix every time. It really kept my interest, as I would pick out new things to hear every time. Everything is now so short that I have the chance to hear things repeat if the ride goes into crawl mode.
Who composed this new soundtrack? What else have they done? This soundtrack really lacked emotional response. In the old soundtrack, the experience started before you even entered the ride. I liked the sense of mystery of the music on the assent, where are we from, where are we going? Then of course, it all ends with the soundtrack fading into wind, as if the dream is over, return to reality now. It really was cinematic. Where did that go? I want to have my mood changed several times during a 17 minute attraction, the new one leaves me with no feelings of any kind. No thought about the future, no contemplation of the message just conveyed, nothing.
This is really the disappointment. Most Disney attractions involve a story, emotional response, and a message to take away. Some are just whimsical fun, like Splash Mountain. However, Epcot used to be all about the message. It had real spirit. I still see that spirit in the World Showcase. I also see it in The Land, as everything does tie together well in that building. The story around the Living Seas made sense, and established the reason for the undersea environment presented to guests. Something tells me that they would have removed the aquarium if they really could avoid the PR nightmare. Now, its Nemo and Crush, but with a bunch of aquariums to look at while you wait to see the show, or while you're waiting for people to get out of the gift shop. I walked around the aquarium a few times on my past trip. It was seriously deserted, nobody really wanted to look at the displays.
I honestly think that when we lose Illuminations Reflections of Earth, its all over. Consider Epcot to be an entirely different animal from its childhood. Hey, at least we've still got the American Adventure right?
Ryan