PizzaSpringRoll2017
Member
The issue is that in a movie, you’re staring up close at the actors the entire time and it all seems more grounded in reality. On stage you can just cast for voice and general appearance because it seems less literal, it’s farther away and you don’t get a great up close look at characters for very long. Movies generally just seem more “real” than musicals, even when it’s the same plot. It’s the reason the cannibalism in Sweeney Todd was a funny punchline in the show, but seemed gory and disturbing in the movie. Or why when the plant eats everyone in Little Shop of Horrors it seems hilarious and fun on stage, but was kind of depressing in the original cut of the movieIdina would have been 31 and Kristen 34 when it premiered. Ariana is currently 30 and Cynthia 37. I don't know if it's that out of whack. I realize it's a movie and not to take away from any of your other points though.
I think what Universal really should’ve done was an animated adaptation right after Frozen, with the full original cast. Musical fans get an awesome animated faithful adaptation, little girls get Let It Go 2 with Idinas big songs, and Universal gets their first smash hit Disney style musical avoiding all the issues with live action. What a timeline that would have been