You will start WW3 with a post like this.
I'm just the messenger.
I mean think about it. Peter Pan's flight by all modern standards is a crappy ride.
People question the longevity of ET and that is basically a more modern more advanced ripoff of that ride concept and yet nobody seems to doubt that PPF, a low capacity ride with decades old effects - especially at WDW where we never got the same updates DL did - will be around until the end of time.
Why is that?
Is it because it's
actually a great ride?
If an adult were to ride that for the very first time today, would they think it's an amazing ride worthy of the waits it gets or would it seem like a crappy outdated ride that they don't get the hype over?
That attraction's longevity is rooted
firmly in nostalgia.
If Universal had opened that today instead of Disney 50+ years ago, everyone would rightly call it crap.
I'm a part of the nostalgia crowd so I'm in no way trying to knock anyone who likes PPF. I don't want to see it close, either.
... but my son who, due to certain Disney business choices that alienated me, didn't get the same deeply rooted connection to the brand and the parks over his early childhood like I did will never feel the same way about any of this that I do.
When he grows up and has to spend his own money to go to a park with his kids, he's not going to see a 70-80 year old ride as favorably compared to whatever the current version of Minions is or Cosmic Rewhind when it comes to where he takes
his kids.
Will attractions like this survive that?
Will our pirates remain a classic or will it end up being replaced by something closer to what they have in Shanghai?
Even today, while many of us don't want to see that happen, there are already plenty who do.
Disney can't cater to both and one group is literally a dying breed while the new group who has no attachment to the "old" stuff that wasn't a part of their own childhood as much (or at all) are going to become the majority. They're going to say "why am I spending $600 a ticket to take my kids to do these old crappy rides?"
I'm pretty sure the Bobs broke that chain and I don't think there's going to be any going back, now.
There's Disney stuff that many would have called sacred for much of the last 75 years out there that many if not most of younger generations will not see that way going forward. They won't be able to milk that history the way they used to and I don't think they have anyone to blame but themselves for that.