Those Precious 2 Credits....

real mad hatter

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
Now wither you've payed for your DDP or got it free:happy:...We all enjoy a good dining experience. But when it comes to a restaurant that reqs 2 credits..We definitely want a good dining experience..So for all you 2 credit experts out there..What restaurant do you think is definitely not worth a 2 credit rating.? And why?
 

DisneyDebNJ

Well-Known Member
Personally, I don't think any restaurant on Disney property is worth 2 dining credits per person. (Let the flaming begin... LOL) Unless you get free dining and opt to upgrade to deluxe. Having said that, signatures we really like (and usually pay OOP for) are Le Cellier (never had a bad meal here) and Narcoossee's. We are doing several signature restaurants this year (yep free dining and upgraded) From what I am told, Yachtsman's is exceptional (kudos to @sgtmgd ... yes we are going this year, thank you!)
 

real mad hatter

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
Easy one for me to answer ... La cellier.
Tried it and found it not nice at all (just my opinion before i get burnt at the stake eh)
i have noticed a lot of people who (whilst they like it ) also agree it should be a 1 credit
I agree..We dined there in 2008 after reading all the great reviews..That year we weren't on any DDP but the whole hype of this steakhouse went down quicker than the Titanic..ADR booked 6 months in advance..Three of us seated in a way too small table right at the door..Poor server..Average steaks..Mrs Hatter and I had the Signature fillets..Bill was over $200. ....:(....:cry:...
 

gjpjtj

Well-Known Member
Easy one for me to answer ... La cellier.
Tried it and found it not nice at all (just my opinion before i get burnt at the stake eh)
i have noticed a lot of people who (whilst they like it ) also agree it should be a 1 credit

I have to agree. Le Cellier is one of my favorite WDW restaurants, however I have stopped going since it went to 2 credits. Rather use that on something special. Just not worth it.:(
 
Last edited:

sxeensweet

Love a little Disney every day!! ;)
I have to agree. La Cellier is one of my favorite WDW restaurants, however I have stopped going since it went to 2 credits. Rather use that on something special. Just not worth it.:(
We absolutely love Le Cellier 2 credits or not!!! We travel a lot and always dine at several nicer , fancier restaurants and the service and food is on par with the top places we have been. We gladly pay what it costs or use 2 credits and we go every single trip. Never had less than a delicious meal and superb service. Prices are equivilant to any places we have been with similiar experiences. We have even paid more at a few and think Le Cellier was better than those. Lol So I really never get the bad rep this place gets. Frankly finer dining is never a "good value" no matter where you go at WDW or anywhere else. We don't go for value we go for a nice meal with great service. On that note we personally did not care for Narcoosees out of the Sigs. So if I had to pick one I don't care for it would be there. We had the surf and turf and it was nothing to brag about and our steaks were not cooked right either. I don't really remember any of the food we ate being that good. That is probably the one we will not go back to out of all the Signatures. So I gave our fave and least fave for you Mr. Hatter. :)
 

LucyK

Well-Known Member
Any that has the name steakhouse attached to it. Not because of quality but because it would be a waste of money/credit going to a restaurant and not ordering the dishes they are famous for. Like a person who doesn't like fish going to Fulton's or Flying Fish.
 

zurgandfriend

Well-Known Member
We haven't been to le Cellier for a while but from past experience I don't think it's a 2 credit restaurant. Artist Point to us isn't a 2 credit restaurant, others will disagree I'm sure. The dinner shows are not worth 2 credits either again just my opinion.
 
Last edited:

englanddg

One Little Spark...
We haven't been to le Cellier for a while but I from past experience I don't think it's a 2 credit restaurant. Artist Point to us isn't a 2 credit restaurant, others will disagree I'm sure. The dinner shows are not worth 2 credits either again just my opinion.
Le Cellier used to be a 1 credit for lunch...but they changed that this year.

It's 2 credits for lunch or dinner.
 

RandomPrincess

Keep Moving Forward
We were really disappointed at Le Cellier in Feb 2012. We went to the 1 point lunch and I'm not sure if we just order the wrong things or what but all four adults did not enjoy their meals. Now that it is 2 points we won't be going back any time soon.
 

wdwfan4ver

Well-Known Member
Le Cellier. I never went there as a two credit place, but the food went down hill the last time I went there and the place never worth 2 credits to me even when I had good food there.

I'm never going back to Le Cellier, but I want to thank them for my bad experience. Without the bad experience at Le Cellier, I wouldn't have tried Trails End and Chefs De France as 1 credit table services places that I had great meals at.
 

Weather_Lady

Well-Known Member
For me, any 2-credit restaurant that doesn't cost at least twice what a 1-credit restaurant would isn't worth the dining credits (which means, NONE of them are worth 2 credits).

To do a really rudimentary calculation, let's try and figure out the approximate "dollar value" of a table service credit. The DDP (2014 pricing, I think) is $59 a day for an adult. Assume you're buying lunch at Columbia Harbor House (entree, drink and dessert cost about $18 altogether) and having a Dole Whip ($5) as your snack. That means that in order to break even with the out-of-pocket costs for the same items, your table service entree/dessert/beverage combination needs to be worth at least $36. (Of course, if you ate a less expensive counter service meal or didn't use all your snack credits, you'd have to work even harder to break even.)

So assuming that each table service credit is worth $36 or more, two of them are worth at least $72. Thus, unless you are going somewhere for dinner that will cost you at least that much (and I cannot think of a single meal that has that steep a pricetag -- I'm sure you could get that total somewhere, but you'd be straining to order the most expensive options instead of what you necessarily watned to eat), you're getting less than full value for your dining plan credits if you go to a 2-credit meal.

We like to try "2-credit" experiences on every trip, but if we're on the dining plan, we never use it for them: we pay out of pocket instead and "spend" our dining credits on 1-credit meals instead. Better yet, we forego the dining plan and spread our dining between restaurants that offer great value, and multiple signature (2-credit) experiences.
 

EvilQueen-T

Well-Known Member
Le Cellier since the last time I went the steak tasted like it was boiled. Narcoossee's has become sooooo hit or miss on the food and the service. The character meals aren't really worth 2 credits to me unless the point is to take the kids. The food is just blah. Our favorites are Citricos, Flying Fish, Yachtsman's, and Artist Point.
 

DisneyDebNJ

Well-Known Member
Any that has the name steakhouse attached to it. Not because of quality but because it would be a waste of money/credit going to a restaurant and not ordering the dishes they are famous for. Like a person who doesn't like fish going to Fulton's or Flying Fish.
I sort of agree with you.... my son has gone to Fulton's many times and does not eat seafood, however loves their filet mignon, however, I see your point. I rarely eat beef, but my ADRs for this year include Le Cellier and Yachtsman's Steakhouse.
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom