Kevin_W
Well-Known Member
Controversial opinion: most of the Pixar scores just aren't that good.
Yes, there are some wonderful exceptions to that rule (mostly the Giacchino ones, like Ratatouille and Up), but they're largely forgettable. Avoiding any of the songs with lyrics, can you hum the score to Toy Story? How about Monsters, Inc? Or Cars, maybe? They do a serviceable job in the background of their respective films, but just aren't especially impressive on their own
We saw the Columbus symphony orchestra perform the Pixar in concert last weekend. Going in, I had the same thought (I'd happily take Menken over either of the Newmans). Even though most of the themes are not as memorable (Up and Incredibles, for me) they still fit the movies very well. Combined with the montage clips on the screen t was still a really enjoyable concert