Our most recent trip (Feb 10th-15th this year) we had booked four nights at Boardwalk Villas. We decided we wanted to add an extra night (for 5 total vs 4) and did not want to pay a lot. We booked our first night at POP and we loved it. Our last 5 trips have been CSR, CSR, Wilderness Lodge, WL again, and Boardwalk.
I must say I was concerned that I would not like the resort after staying deluxe, but it was perfect for what we were doing. The layout is great, the food hall wonderful, and the theming was top notch. Dare I say that it was even better than the boardwalk for my 8 month old.
Of all the resorts we have been to we love WL the most, but POP definitely held its own with CSR and Boardwalk. This is not a knock on the other two, but more the high regard we held for POP.
Next year we are looking to go in April or May and are probably going to split our stay with 3 nights at POP and the last 3-4 nights at Poly in order to save a few bucks. The room could have been bigger (esp with a baby + pack n play), but amazing value for the money and definitely was more of a Disney feel then CSR and Boardwalk.